Skip to content


Thread Subject: Discussion S5E6 -- Family

DO NOT POST - Backup in Progress

Thread Subject: Discussion S5E6 -- Family

Postby november » Wed Nov 08, 2000 12:58 pm

posted 11-08-2000 14:58 EST (US)
Hi all . . . while I've been lurking (and reading with great enjoyment) for a while, this is my first post, so I hope I'm doing this right. What's brought me out of lurkdom is "Family" . . . After living in fear for a few weeks that Tara, whom I love, would turn out to be bad and subsequently get the axe, I can't tell you a) how relieved I am that she's apparently turned out to be good, and b) how absolutely DELIGHTED/THRILLED I am that Joss resolved the mystery in such a heartwarming episode! This was Buffy at its best. I could gush on (and on, and on) for another few thousand word, but I'll give others thir chance to rave instead.
november
 


Thread Subject: Discussion S5E6 -- Family

Postby Zelda » Wed Nov 08, 2000 1:22 pm

posted 11-08-2000 15:22 EST (US)
Welcome november. Now that you've delurked, head over to the Introduction thread and let us know more. We're a greed bunch.

And I agree with you, not only did I enjoy the episode but I was relieved. Good times all around.

Zelda
 


Thread Subject: Discussion S5E6 -- Family

Postby Hugin » Wed Nov 08, 2000 1:41 pm

posted 11-08-2000 15:41 EST (US)
I think the camel thing was just silliness. But isnt there some sort of metaphor or analogy that related to camels getting partway into a tent? If I remember correctly (which I freely admit I probably don't) it has something or other to do with slippery slopes, that once you let a little bit of an idea in, it's as bad (or good) as accepting the whole thing. So maybe the half camel was supposed to be a reference to the continuing issues Joss has to deal with with society and WB execs and such in order to do right by W/T. He's managed to get half the camel in the tent.

Okay, I'm re-reading that and it looks completely incoherent, so I'm going to go back to 'they were being cute and silly'.

-len

Hugin
 


Thread Subject: Discussion S5E6 -- Family

Postby Spring » Wed Nov 08, 2000 1:46 pm

posted 11-08-2000 15:46 EST (US)
Actually Len, that's the best explanation I ever heard in my entire life (No, really!) The reason why I think it's not JUST them being silly is that :
a) Joss wrote the ep
b) Joss directed the ep
c) Half a camel is really just gross. I mean, it's half an anima, that's disgusting- that's not silly or cute, that's like you know a magic trick gone awry (like cutting the lady in half). Camels spit all the time and are smelly and dirty animals.
I'm staking a lot on this camel reference, but I gather it's something symbolic about sex.
Camel is a hump backed animal, half a camel is one that well, has no humped back- see? Of course this isn't the dirty reference I mentioned earlier, just me a ramblin'.
Spring
 


Thread Subject: Discussion S5E6 -- Family

Postby TyRex316 » Wed Nov 08, 2000 1:48 pm

posted 11-08-2000 15:48 EST (US)
Isn't it just like willow to want an animal that you never hear about in fairy tales to be in hers. kinda of a 'it's not fair camels are left out of things like this.' so willow included one.
TyRex316
 


Thread Subject: Discussion S5E6 -- Family

Postby Rane » Wed Nov 08, 2000 1:54 pm

posted 11-08-2000 15:54 EST (US)
ok. i'm getting tired of all this camel bashing! they are not dirty, smelly animals. friggin horses are exactly the same. camels are amazing animals that survive in the harshest of regions and are extremely helpful to humans. so what if they spit? everyone spits. it's not like they look to aim at people. cats fart, or at least my best friends did. and dogs rummage through garbage, cats too. ferrets stink more than any other animal i have ever known. i love camels and was extremely glad i was able to ride one even though it scared the begeebies out of me at first. i've been to camel nurseries and they are the friendliest and cutest animals in the world. ok, i'm exagerating but you get my point.

and yes I am half serious!

------------------
*a few thoughts on the subject by a lil' nothing*, Rasputina

Rane
 


Thread Subject: Discussion S5E6 -- Family

Postby Zelda » Wed Nov 08, 2000 1:58 pm

posted 11-08-2000 15:58 EST (US)
I'm kind of a dog person myself.

Anyway, has anyone mentioned the little foot action that Willow gives Tara when she's coyly telling Tara she doesn't need snuggles?

And I must say that the "he hurt my nose" comment was begging for a kiss on the nose -- followed naturally with an "OUCH."

Zelda
 


Thread Subject: Discussion S5E6 -- Family

Postby Spring » Wed Nov 08, 2000 2:11 pm

posted 11-08-2000 16:11 EST (US)
I clearly understand now that Tara was referencing Nietzsche, like DUH!:

In the "Three Metamorphoses" section of Also Sprach Zarathustra, Nietzsche describes "How the spirit becomes a camel; and the
camel, a lion; and the lion, finally, a child." This parable is autobiographical and casts light on Nietzsche's spiritual journey from
discipleship to Wagner to being a "free-spirit" [freier Geist] who bequeathed to posterity a philosophy that shines brightly in the
heavens as an eternal testament to thought of the highest rank. Nietzsche claims that his painful struggles to become fully himself and
to achieve mastery are hardly unique but hold universal lessons, "As it happened to me...so it must happen to everyone in which a
task wants to take form [in dem Aufgabe leibhaft werden] and come into the world."

[This message has been edited by Spring (edited 11-08-2000).]

Spring
 


Thread Subject: Discussion S5E6 -- Family

Postby Hugin » Wed Nov 08, 2000 3:02 pm

posted 11-08-2000 17:02 EST (US)
I didn't see the foot thing Zelda, I'll have to watch for it on tape (oh darn).

But did you notice the little back rub thing Willow gave Tara during the dancing, right when they got closer together? I liked that a lot. Very couple-y.

-len

Hugin
 


Thread Subject: Discussion S5E6 -- Family

Postby Rane » Wed Nov 08, 2000 3:40 pm

posted 11-08-2000 17:40 EST (US)
i didn't notice the footsie but i did notice how they slipped a reaction shot of Tara after Buffy asked where Dawn was (concerned) and she (dawn) walks into the dorm room. Tara nodded as in *she's here, she's ok* kinda way. i was intrigued by this. They could have edited in anyone else. Maybe Joss just wanted more Amber. don't we all.

------------------
*a few thoughts on the subject by a lil' nothing*, Rasputina

Rane
 


Thread Subject: Discussion S5E6 -- Family

Postby SciFiAcid » Wed Nov 08, 2000 5:08 pm

posted 11-08-2000 19:08 EST (US)
I totally saw the footsie! Beyond adorableness. Not only that, but when Tara was leaving with the box from Buffy's room, and Willow came up to her to tell her to start taking boxes out to the car... Willow puts her hand over Tara's, which is holding on to the box. Than as Tara leaves, Willow brushes her hand over her elbow. Man, I love those little intimate touches! I'm wondering, at this point, if it's just something Aly's automatically interjecting into scenes? Or something the directors/writers are still putting in? Of course, Tara's less touchy, but maybe that'll change now!

Touch-a touch-a... um, oops, wrong thread


------------------
Life if it was sweet,
would mean your touch is complete.
Around my mind forever
simply one love divine... together.

SciFiAcid
 


Thread Subject: Discussion S5E6 -- Family

Postby Roxton » Wed Nov 08, 2000 6:28 pm

posted 11-08-2000 20:28 EST (US)
A few more thoughts on "Family"


  • I loved the way that once again Spike was able to reveal the obvious, that the demon curse was simply manipulation by the male members of Tara's family. He has such a gift for that.

  • You had to feel sorry for Tara's cousin at the end. In spite of what happened she couldn't bring herself to admit that she too was being manipulated. She was totally brainwashed. It's sad to see something like that happen.

  • Did anyone else get the impression that Tara's brother was stupid. After seeing the Scoobies defeat those demons he still physically threatened Tara. That was dumb. I almost wished he had tried something and got his butt kicked.

  • I have to wonder what was Sandy's role last night. Does she have designs on Riley.

  • It was great to see the Scoobies come to-gether for the whole episode. Maybe this is a sign of things to come.

  • I wonder what is driving some of the residents of Sunnydale crazy. Is it Glory's presence in town or could this be some side effect of Dawn.

[This message has been edited by Roxton (edited 11-08-2000).]

Roxton
 


Thread Subject: Discussion S5E6 -- Family

Postby cparga » Wed Nov 08, 2000 8:59 pm

posted 11-08-2000 22:59 EST (US)
[QUOTE]Originally posted by Roxton:

  • I wonder what is driving some of the residents of Sunnydale crazy. Is it Glory's presence in town or could this be some side effect of Dawn.

    Hmmmm...I was wondering this too, if Dawn has anything to do with the raging insanity afflicting Sunnydale. I'm sure I'm reading too much into this, but I couldn't help but go "hmmmm..." when Buffy says to Riley regarding Dawn that Dawn "drives her crazy". Just maybe Dawn is driving everyone crazy??
    Or maybe I'm the crazy one...

    Cylinda

  • xita posted 11-09-2000 12:08 EST (US)
    Adrienne, that's cause Willow's the butch

    I just wanted to say again, that Tara had better looks for willow during the dance. Willow's best looks were when Tara comes inside the covers, and she's looking up at her.. ahhh.. and when she says my dance. I also noticed Aly's voice was much softer than the more hysterical tone she sometimes gets when she's emotional. It was weird at first, but it's kind of cool.

    heathergalaxy posted 11-09-2000 12:22 EST (US)
    i'm soo sad! i didn't have enough time to write my critical analysis tonight... oh well...

    but i did want to mention a few things.

    i'm thinking the sally thing was a red herring. yknow, joss trying to slip us up and make us think that this had to do with doppelgangland... which we all totally fell for!

    i totally saw the footsie, the brush, and the hand... i also saw that look tara gave as buffy is looking for dawn. my interpretation was that tara was thinking 'good. buffy is taking care of dawn like she is supposed to.'

    did anyone else notice the clothing color scheme for family? very deliberate, imho...

    i'm just glad we solved the 'is that xander or xander's dummy?' issue!

    xita posted 11-09-2000 12:56 EST (US)
    I don't think Tara looking at Buffy and Dawn is significant. I actually saw this as a walk in the shoes of Tara day. In that first scene, we something we had never seen. We see her react to the other people in the gang. We know she thinks xander is a sweetie. When riley and xander are wrestling, we see her reaction, she thinks they are funny. When she sees Buffy's caring for Dawn, she approves. When she throws in an awful joke, she is self depricating I loved this more a lot. Poor Tara, there's been so much going on that we haven't seen cause she's so good at putting up a good face.
    Roxton posted 11-09-2000 11:07 EST (US)
    Now that we know what her family is like I can't help but wonder if Tara might be looking at at Riley, Xander, Dawn and Buffy and wishing, "if only my family could have been like that". Just a thought.
    Spring posted 11-09-2000 11:24 EST (US)
    Well:

    • Riley was obviously tank grown from hybrid alien/human DNA and implanted into Iowa as part of the cover a secret government program.[see X-files for the full story]
    • Xander comes from creepily abusive parents who we never see but only know through not-so-positive references
    • Dawn? Don't EVEN get me started on Dawn, she who is made of pure energy and given human form by Czech monks
    • Buffy, well her home life hasn't been the swellest

    If anything, I'm sure Tara's been thinking all along that with their respective family backgrounds she fits right in.

    wolliw posted 11-09-2000 11:26 EST (US)
    Apologies if this has already been mentioned, but yet *another* nice touch in Family was Xander suggesting "back oils" as a present for Tara. Suggests some nice imagery for moi ....
    Spring posted 11-09-2000 11:30 EST (US)
    I thought it was 'bath oils' you naughty freudian be-slipped vixen!
    april posted 11-09-2000 11:31 EST (US)
    actually, i think he said "bath oils", but the image is still a nice one...

    i have so much i want to say about "family", but no time to type it! i depart on a 4-day trip to atlanta in an hour...

    wolliw posted 11-09-2000 11:41 EST (US)
    Oops, thanks spring, April -- I stand bashfully corrected! (In my dialect of English, I pronounce 'bath' with the vowel like the one in 'father'.) I was wondering why no one seemed to have mentioned this; but "bath oils" is still nice, if for some reason less naughty-sounding ....
    april posted 11-09-2000 12:14 EST (US)
    oh, i think baths can be pretty darn naughty, too...

    spring, once again we're on the same wavelength. found any good toys, er, "crystals", lately?

    those naughty wiccans...

    tyche posted 11-09-2000 12:26 EST (US)
    My computer has been broken for the last few days (in fact, it broke on Sunday night so maybe the extreme joyfulness after reading the spoilers had something to do with it), but I just wanted to say that, from what I've seen & heard, it looks like an amazing ep. Amber looked totally gorgeous.. *sigh* And the cuteness factor! And W & T on a bed together! And the return of MKF! And I have to stop now or I am just going to gush for hours. But I am SO glad that W & T finally got to act like a couple in public. (Is it the first time this season that they've been able to do something traditionally 'coupley'? Not having seen S5 I am ignorant on this - it's only when you actually see an ep that things like this hit you..)
    Joss is a genius. Let us worship him.
    Little Willow posted 11-09-2000 12:58 EST (US)
    Welcome from lurkerdom, November!
    Little Willow posted 11-09-2000 12:59 EST (US)
    For everyone wondering about Beth --

    Tara calls her "Cousin Beth" when they first arrive. You'll notice that the
    voiceover was looped; the close captioning initially reads simply, "Hey,
    Beth." I believe in postproduction they realized they had to make clear
    Beth wasn't a sister, or even mother, to those who weren't certain.

    If Beth hasn't hit 20 yet, that could be why she didn't know the truth and
    still believes in the "demon."

    If she has, it was theorized that she could be from a different side of the
    family that "doesn't" have the "demon" in them - could even be adopted, or a
    girlfriend / married into the family, otherwise not blood related, et al.

    If she has, she could also have just been told she looks like a demon, etc.
    Mental abuse can make you think things and see things that aren't there.
    Think of the Twilight Zone classic... It's all about the eye of the
    beholder.

    Speaking of Twilight Zone:

    Why oh why did, the very second Beth appeared, I instantly relate Twilight
    Zone to her? I think it was a combination of the ballerina from "Five
    Characters in Search of an Exit" and the blond woman in an episode I cannot
    recall the title of - Someone, anyone, have the title for this? - The
    episode that dealt with the folk legend of the two friends, the brunette
    ex-involved with a man and the blond about to marry him, when the brunette
    casts a spell (with the help of the local witch-type) to make the man turn
    to her instead.

    Does anyone else see this TZBeth issue or am I completely alone?

    Little Willow
    feeling old ::

    ----------------------
    "Magic." -- Willow http://www.amberbenson.net/ http://little__willow.tripod.com/wpwp.html http://www.gist.com/tvclubs/fanclub.jsp?fanclub=buffy

    Little Willow posted 11-09-2000 13:04 EST (US)
    Scrolled around and one more topic to address for now: Dawn.

    Willow and Tara have both been very Dawn-supportive since REAL ME.

    Some quick examples. Including but not limited to.

    Willow has consisted let Buffy confide in her about Dawn's 'annoying' level, but she relates to Dawn due to 'spaz' and tries to get Buffy to go easy on her.

    NOTE when Willow calls the younger girl "Dawny" (Donny, much?) in RM.

    Tara had the thumb wrestling with Dawn, the discussion about Dawn with Willow, et al in Real Me. Then in Family we distinctly see various reactions shots (go Joss) of Tara regarding Dawn.

    As per Tara's "sense" of things (see Hush, TYG, Superstar, WtWTA and more) - I wouldn't be surprised if she beyond anyone else DID know more about Dawn, by either her studies, her knowledge, or simply her 'sense.'

    Little Willow


    --------
    "Magic." -- Willow
    http://www.amberbenson.net/
    http://little__willow.tripod.com/wpwp.html
    http://www.gist.com/tvclubs/fanclub.jsp?fanclub=buffy

    [This message has been edited by Little Willow (edited 11-09-2000).]

    spuckie posted 11-09-2000 13:07 EST (US)
    Little Willow - if yer feeling old, i must be fossilizing as we "speak"...

    anyway, yeah, cousin beth's reaction to the non-demon truth was abit odd. Did she know all along it was a ploy to keep down the womenfolk? Does she still believe she and/or tara are demons?

    'nother question, DearOlDad said "the women in our family" are demons. Did he mean HIS family (passed down from the father) or tara's mum's family?

    Spring posted 11-09-2000 13:16 EST (US)
    Thanks for explaining that bit of clunky 'Cousin Beth' dialogue. I was watching with a friend and we both **groaned** when she said that. I guess it was Joss's call to explain Beth's presence, though I would've preferred that Beth's connection to Tara remain ambiguous- it would've been fun to wonder if she was a jealous ex-g/f or something. Not to say that hasn't been ruled out- looking at Tara's family, kinfolk-a-couplin' might not be a completely taboo concept.
    You know, it's people like me with our anti-redneck-backwoods stance and ready incest jokes that kept Tara in the closet about her ancestry. I'm ashamed of myself.....kinda. Willow is such a good girlfriend, and such a better person than me
    ghaliya posted 11-09-2000 14:18 EST (US)
    Interior Design comment.

    I *loved* that new poster in Tara's room. The one with the faces on it. It really adds mystery/complexity to her space. Does anyone recognize it - or know where I can buy one?

    Roxton posted 11-09-2000 16:01 EST (US)
    I don't know if Beth still believed in the demon curse at the end and I doubt if it really mattered. Beth had become so brainwashed as to the role of the women in Tara's family that the simple fact Tara wouldn't return to look after her father and brother was, in her mind, both incomprehensible and unforgivable.

    [This message has been edited by Roxton (edited 11-09-2000).]

    Nouvelle posted 11-09-2000 19:53 EST (US)
    Little Willow, the Twilight Zone episode you're thinking of may be "Jess-Belle". It was a one hour episode from season four that stared James Best (Cleatus from The Dukes of Hazzard). Just scanning over my copy of The Official Twilight Zone Companion I see a pic of Best with two actress, one brunette and one blond and in the episode description I see the words majic and menfolk. If you want the more detailed description let me know. When I saw Cousin Beth my first thought was of The Stepford Wives. Anyone remember that?

    One other thing Little Willow, since you know Amber did she tell you what Taras' secert was going to be? And what's up with her hair? Like I said before she looks totally brunett now. In the earlier episodes she looks very blonde. Is it Joss or Amber who wanted to make the switch? I'm just wonderin. Thanks.

    xita posted 11-09-2000 23:08 EST (US)
    I think Amber's hair looks different when light hits it as well, I mean in addition to any color changes that might have been made. I think everyone is protective of Dawn, not just Willow and Tara and it's because that was implanted in them, along with the fake memories.
    Ham posted 11-10-2000 02:49 EST (US)
    Finally saw the ep after having computer trouble, man it was worth the wait.
    I loved how the ep was all about facial expressions. Amber's smile that starts out all wonky and then just gets grinny is beautiful. Especially in the bed scene (Who'd of thought we'd be able to say bed scene?) and the bit at the end where Beth asks if she's happy. Once again Aly is also a queen of expressions. I hate that that girl can make me teary just by looking a little upset. Who didn't cry during Consequences when Willow found out about Faith and Xander?
    Joss is a god, no doubt now. I promise to never doubt the man again, he knows what he's doing. Not for a long while have we had an episode this romantic and heart wrenching that makes you feel all warm and fuzzy inside. Plus after 6 viewings it still hasn't worn off. I like that Tara was the catalyst for the supposed theme of this season. It was because of her that the Scoobies were all brought together as a family. I feel Dawn will be the one to keep them this way. And now that Tara's a real scooby there'll be no getting rid of her that easily. I'm glad she'll be around in a Scooby capacity for a while.
    I also enjoyed the way Joss compared B/R and W/T during the party. Riley comes in and they're all smoochy but not much spark, then W/T dance and it's electric. And they used the L word again, hurrah.

    The best ep so far, I'm now really waiting for the next Marti ep, For Your Love, that sounds exciting.

    Little Willow posted 11-10-2000 03:12 EST (US)
    quote:
    Originally posted by spuckie:
    Little Willow - if yer feeling old, i must be fossilizing as we "speak"...

    LOL! No!!
    I always feel old. I always say, my age is older than I look, younger than I feel.

    ------------------
    :: she's essential
    www.AmberBenson.net
    :: get willow power
    www.members.tripod.com/little__willow/wpwp.html

    ----------------------------------
    http://little__willow.tripod.com
    http://www.gist.com/tvclubs/fanclub.jsp?fanclub=buffy
    http://www.envy.nu/yourgirl

    Little Willow posted 11-10-2000 03:17 EST (US)
    Nouvelle: "Jess-Belle" is precisely it! THANK YOU! If you watch it, see if I'm nuts about the similarities - and I mean strictly in features of the girls, Cousin Beth is like a hybrid.

    "The Stepford Wives" -- Is there an emoticon for *shudder*?

    Cannot comment on the secret keeping.

    I don't know if the hair change was character-induced. It's just her hair. Usually back in a scrunchie. ;-)

    Little Willow http://www.amberbenson.net/ http://www.envy.nu/yourgirl

    Seaweed posted 11-10-2000 11:52 EST (US)
    Does anyone know what the overnight ratings were for this episode? Did it do well against election coverage?

    Seaweed

    BBOvenGuy posted 11-10-2000 12:02 EST (US)
    According to Enigma at the Cross & Stake:

    quote:
    The WB began the first Tuesday of sweeps with " Buffy, the Vampire Slayer." "Buffy" kicked its way to a 5.1/7. (3.1/5) Wesley pretended to be a vampire at 9 p.m., while "Angel" was away, helped the show to 4.4/6 (last week, " Buffy the Vampire Slayer" 3.1/5).
    xita posted 11-10-2000 12:52 EST (US)
    I think the highest buffy this season was the premiere it was at 5.7. I can't remember. All things considered it did really well. All the episodes this year have picked up from last year.
    Prairiegirl posted 11-10-2000 14:41 EST (US)
    I really liked this episode.

    I was worried for a long time that Tara would become the amazing exploding girlfriend, which is what usually happens on TV. And this didn't happen.

    I was also worried that if she didn't explode, that they would become the typical gay couple on TV, who you can tell that they are the gay couple of the show because they are never intimate with each other, they never touch each other, they never do the little things that people do when they are in love. And instead, this show was full of those kinds of things that people do regardless of sexual orientation.

    I also liked how he tweaked the censors by having every other couple on the show kissing, just to show the inequity in how the gay charactors are treated.

    A couple small niggles. I thought it was odd that Tara didn't introduce Willow to her father. Even if she isn't coming out to him, it seemed incongrious.

    Also, I thought it odd that Willow never asked Tara if she wanted to leave *her*. The leaving was as much about leaving Willow as the rest of her life, and I would have thought Willow would have been more forceful to stop her lover.

    As the charactors in the show have grown up and become more confident in themselves, I like how the charactor of Tara has brought back some of the ackwardness that we all feel. I like the assertiveness that Willow now shows both in the relationship,in the rest of her life, and with the gang.

    There was a big change in Willow's attitude towards the relationship that I wish had been shown on screen, from when she goes from "I was so scared to tell you" to "you are essential". It is now past, but I wish Joss had shown when Willow changed from afraid to accepting to fighting for the relationship.

    As to the acting, quite fun. I often feel that straight people who play gay charactors are still carrying around some subconscious internalized homophobia but I didn't really see that here. Aly, especially, seems to be able to be comfortable physically with Amber, which is nice to see. I expect this will grow with Tara as the charactor becomes more confident, giving Amber more range in this area.

    All in all, I was very very very happy with the episode.

    Zelda posted 11-10-2000 14:53 EST (US)
    On the not introducing Willow to her father front -- Tara did introduce Willow to her brother. She introduced her father to the dominant male in the group. I think there are a variety of reasons she would do that that have nothing to do with closeting her relationship. At a minimum, she may be trying to shield Willow from her father.
    xita posted 11-10-2000 15:33 EST (US)
    I think Willow was disappointed at not being introduced but it's interestint that she introduces him to only the dominant male at the magic shop. Very much intentional.
    I also think that when Willow asks Tara if she wants to leave, she's implying leave me. Afterall, really what has Tara going in Sunnydale that would prevent her from leaving. I think now, she'll feel safer to build more connections. Tara always acted like someone who didn't want to involve themselves in life and now we know why. She was so afraid she would lose it all. It's why she didn't seem to have friends. I think she got involved with Willow because she had not choice. She had to love Willow, it was overpowering. Yet still there, she was willing really not fight actively for Willow and let her choose Oz if she needed to. When Willow danced around the idea of living together, Tara shot her down. Poor Tara was so afraid she would lose it all
    Dave V posted 11-13-2000 11:06 EST (US)
    Hi folks!

    Saw "Family" on Saturday. I was totally spoiled, but my wife and some friends who watched the ep with us were unspoiled. The others all liked the episode. Personally, I was blown away by Joss, Alyson and Amber.

    I cannot add too much to the other great insights posted here. However, I will make an observation. One of the women at work has started watching Buffy regularly this season, and we talk about the show occasionally. Her opinion of same-sex relationships like that of Willow and Tara is that they're "just wrong." However, she liked "Family", especially the part where Willow and the rest of the Scoobies supported Tara and stood up to her father. My co-worker agreed, your family are those who treat you best. Cool.

    Zelda posted 11-13-2000 12:18 EST (US)
    From Cinescape.com -- Review of Family

    'Buffy' Episode Review
    Sidney Williams is back with his latest review of the most recent episode of Buffy the Vampire Slayer. The most recent installment of the series, which was aired on our crazy election night, was titled "Family." Here's what Sid
    has to say about it:

    "Family"

    Tara has been an almost silent member of the Buffy family for sometime now, significant in her relationship with Willow yet defined more by her silence and alienation.

    In "Family," written and directed by series creator, Tara takes center stage, picking up were an aside in an episode last season left off. As Willow and Tara attempted a spell to
    reveal demons, Tara inexplicably sabotaged the spell as Willow concentrated with closed eyes.

    The reason behind that is the focal point for an episode that also features cool demons and utilizes Spike's growing Buffy infatuation while developing the recent revelation that Buffy's "sister" is actually an ancient, mystical key put into the Slayer's hands for safe keeping.

    It's a suspenseful installment, directed with the style fans expect when Whedon takes the helm and acted by Amber Benson as Tara and by guest players as well. Tara's folks
    have that kind of eerie, backwoods feel with hints of simmering anger mixed with dangerous ignorance.

    While Tara and the folks are at the forefront, Buffy's newest nemesis is also at work, proving to be dangerous and not easily stopped. A serious showdown is somewhere in the future.

    Trouble with Riley is also brewing as difficulties regarding his role in Buffy's life. He'd like to stand beside the Slayer,
    but things don't quite seem to work that way.

    The fifth season remains as interesting and engaging as those before, making excellent use of characters and situations.

    cookie monster posted 11-13-2000 20:06 EST (US)
    Hi, I lurk around here but I have just registered so you may be seeing more of me. Anyhow, I have read alot of the spoiler and discussion threads on this board about Family and I have not seen something mentioned about it. That something is when Spike is walking toward Tara to hit her Willow is holding onto Tara's fingers. I know that people watch and rewatch episodes (me included) for the tiniest W/T goodness and I thought it was odd that nobody mentioned this. I only caught this today after numerous viewings so I thought I would put it up here to see if anyone else saw it. That's all I wanted to say so I'm off to the Intro thread.

    cookie monster

    Zelda posted 11-13-2000 21:55 EST (US)
    I can tell you that this is Xita's favorite moment. OK, number 4 favorite moment. I have yet to rewatch the episode to see this moment, though I have been tipped off to its existence.

    Welcome Cookie Monster

    [This message has been edited by Zelda (edited 11-13-2000).]

    Roxton posted 11-13-2000 22:31 EST (US)
    Cookie, you would almost think that Willow and Spike had the same idea and were acting in unison. Although given Spike's ability to point out the obvious I think it was more likely he saw Willow holding onto Tara and took advantage of the situation. That was a great scene. Tara's reaction to Spike hitting her, then everyone's reaction to what Spike had just done and finally the way Spike summed it all up.
    xita posted 11-13-2000 23:02 EST (US)
    Ah yes Zelda, 4th favorite moment. Sometimes we chat about things in the chat room, I forget we haven't posted it here. I have to give scificacid credit for tipping me off to the finger hold. I love it. At this point, Willow still think Tara is a demon. She has just found out she's been lied to for a long time. And yet, as soon as Tara tells her it hasn't all be lies and that she wants to stay, Willow (and I know it was Willow) reaches for Tara's finger, in front of her father even. She has to let her know everything is alright with them. VERY nice touch.
    april posted 11-14-2000 15:02 EST (US)
    are there any good screencaps of the "tara finger moment"? (as opposed to the "willow hand moment"...goodness this sounds naughty!)

    as i babbled about at length in today's OT thread, i've been away, and haven't been able to partake in "family" discussion nearly as much as i'd like. i just wanted to mention a few things:

    i know this has been discussed by little willow and the gang over at amberbenson.net, but one of my very favorite moments in "family" is at the end of the scene where the scoobies stand up for tara. cousin beth bbitterly asks tara "are you happy now?", and in response, tara just lets this huge *smile* slowly spread across her face. i *love* this moment. you can totally see tara thinking about all the wonderful things that her future holds with willow and her new family. this is as close to perfect as a scene can get.

    i must admit that there's one thing that baffles me about the tara's secret situation: i know that tara is shy, and was very, very frightened about her (blood-relation) family, what she thought she was going to become, and how the scoobies were going to react. i *know* how hard it is for people who've been in emotionally and physically abusive situations to talk about personal problems, especially one as complicated and dangerous as the problem that tara thought she had.

    but why, *why* didn't she think that she could talk to the scoobies, or at least willow, about her "demonic side"? at the very least, couldn't she have mentioned it to *anya*?! she couldn't possibly have thought that anya would have objected to someone who was part demon. and she knew that the scoobies had befriended and dated all sorts of supernatural-type people, including vampires, werewolves, and other demons. she even saw them save oz in NMR after he turned into an obviously dangerous creature and was captured. they would totally have been willing to try and help her out, help her contol the demonic side that she thought was going to emerge. giles and willow could have found useful spells, anya could have offered practical tips, even spike, if he were in the mood, could have been helpful. were i in tara's place, i would have asked the scoobies for help as soon as i'd learned about them and the other supernatural people they'd befriended.

    and in a more superficial observation, as long as w & t wear floral prints like those worn in the dance scene, the name of this board is in no jeopardy...

    all in all, though, i give "family" lots of "woos", even more "hoos", and crate upon crate of extra flamey candles.

    Spring posted 11-14-2000 15:32 EST (US)
    Well, I'm going to try to answer this one. Tara was afraid that Willow would reject her exactly because of what happened with Oz. Willow's reasoning for not getting together with Oz again are complex, but one of the reasons why Oz did leave in the end was that he could not control his dark side - yes there's acceptance, but also romantic rejection. It could be argued that seeing how Oz was treated, and seeing what really happens to you when you have a demon inside of you, that was the last thing she wanted Willow, of all people, to know about her. Although Oz is not rejected as a person, he is rejected as a lover because he cannot control that side of himself, and Tara believes that she will probably not be able to control that about herself either. Perhaps Tara wanted to avoid it as long as possible so that she could bask in their relationship for the short time (in her mind) that they could be together, before they eventually would have to break up due to her demon-ness. A real fear of Tara's could be causing physical harm to Willow in her demon state, so I wouldn't be surprised if Tara already had a plan for leaving Sunnydale behind as soon as her demon self turned out to be uncontrollably evil. Due to Tara's low self esteem , she might've expected Willow to break up with her on the spot, because Willow wouldn't want another relationship with a demon since the last one turned out so badly.
    Although Anya is an ex-demon, the emphasis here is that she is a human being now, so her situation is not that similar to Tara's. Spike isn't the friendliest demon on the planet either and if it weren't for that chip in his head, it's been implied that Scooby snacks would be the first thing on the menu after he got un-chipped. In the case of Angel, if he 'gets with' Buffy, he will turn into a really, really bad person - so you can see all these demon types aren't exactly goody-goodies. In all the Scoobies are, as far as we know, human (Giles, Buffy, Willow, Xander, and Anya). And Dawn is a human girl with energy inside? I don't even know what to call Dawn, but Tara percieves her as being human.

    [This message has been edited by Spring (edited 11-14-2000).]

    spuckie posted 11-14-2000 16:35 EST (US)
    excellent ideas why tara kept things secret from the scoobies. I'd only like to add that if tara had never told anyone about her demon side, then even wouldbe supporters like the scoobs wouldn't be enuf to overcome her fears of rejection/self-hate etc etc. She was emotionally, and given big bro's attitude, potentially physically abused by her family. It would take a major emotional crisis (ie like the arrival of said family) to bring tara to talking about all this and looking for help.
    xita posted 11-17-2000 23:11 EST (US)
    Something else I like. When Willow goes over to ask Tara to dance, she gives her the what from now on will be known as the universal lesbian touch. You know the one, the one from Superstar, starting at the elbow ending at the hand. I think Tara gives a similar touch to Willow in Where the Wild Things Are. And I am told there was a similar one between Bianca and Rain in AMC (though ABC News and the election made sure I didn't watch it). Anyway, I really like that touch in Family.
    ghaliya posted 11-17-2000 23:16 EST (US)
    xita, combined with that look willow gives tara when she says "my dance"....sigh....
    yeah i know, sappy romantic fool
    xita posted 11-17-2000 23:20 EST (US)
    Yes, I think I am starting to resemble Spike That look is great! And also, why is Willow not wearing shoes when she's floating?

    Ok, last comment. I love the way Aly keeps looking at Amber's lips there at the end! I know I would sneak a few looks myself!

    [This message has been edited by xita (edited 11-17-2000).]

    darvangi posted 11-17-2000 23:26 EST (US)
    Yeah, I wondered where Willow's shoes went too, but only for a second because I was too distracted by the sight of Tara's hideous sandals. Get thee to a Gap, witch woman.
    Spring posted 11-17-2000 23:30 EST (US)
    Lesbian. Witch. Birkenstocks. Duh.
    Corporeal Dennis posted 11-18-2000 12:05 EST (US)
    quote:
    Originally posted by Spring:
    Lesbian. Witch. Birkenstocks. Duh.

    You tell 'em, Spring!

    ObWardrobe: My favorites were Tara's Doc Martens in "This Year's Girl", though.
    Which episode also featured one of the least-flattering shirts ever to exist, also on Tara.

    --Dennis

    BBOvenGuy posted 11-18-2000 12:12 EST (US)
    quote:
    Originally posted by xita:
    When Willow goes over to ask Tara to dance, she gives her the what from now on will be known as the universal lesbian touch. You know the one, the one from Superstar, starting at the elbow ending at the hand. I think Tara gives a similar touch to Willow in Where the Wild Things Are. And I am told there was a similar one between Bianca and Rain in AMC (though ABC News and the election made sure I didn't watch it).

    Vampire Willow also gave it to Sandy in "Doppelgangland."

    Zahir posted 11-18-2000 12:20 EST (US)
    I understand perfectly why Tara didn't tell anyone of her "demon-ness."

    Fear. And shame.

    Remember she is *not* experienced when it comes to love, or friendship. Most likely she was (and still is, btw) terrified of losing either. In other words, she doesn't want to rock the boat.

    As for shame, she's been programmed by her family to feel exactly that about herself. Not merely her "demon" self, but the whole package (Donnie's casual threat of physical violence with no reproof from their father was chilling). Like the lesbian who remains in the closet even amongst the tolerant, Tara stayed in her closet (not that there's a metaphor going on here or anything).

    ------------------
    "O let my name be
    in the Book of Love.
    If it be there,
    I care not of
    That other book Above...
    Strike it out!
    Or write it in anew.
    But let it be
    in the Book of Love!"
    --Omar Kyam

    cparga
     


    Thread Subject: Discussion S5E6 -- Family

    Postby Roxton » Thu Nov 09, 2000 9:07 am

    posted 11-09-2000 11:07 EST (US)
    Now that we know what her family is like I can't help but wonder if Tara might be looking at at Riley, Xander, Dawn and Buffy and wishing, "if only my family could have been like that". Just a thought.
    Roxton
     


    Thread Subject: Discussion S5E6 -- Family

    Postby Spring » Thu Nov 09, 2000 9:24 am

    posted 11-09-2000 11:24 EST (US)
    Well:

    • Riley was obviously tank grown from hybrid alien/human DNA and implanted into Iowa as part of the cover a secret government program.[see X-files for the full story]
    • Xander comes from creepily abusive parents who we never see but only know through not-so-positive references
    • Dawn? Don't EVEN get me started on Dawn, she who is made of pure energy and given human form by Czech monks
    • Buffy, well her home life hasn't been the swellest

    If anything, I'm sure Tara's been thinking all along that with their respective family backgrounds she fits right in.

    Spring
     


    Thread Subject: Discussion S5E6 -- Family

    Postby wolliw » Thu Nov 09, 2000 9:26 am

    posted 11-09-2000 11:26 EST (US)
    Apologies if this has already been mentioned, but yet *another* nice touch in Family was Xander suggesting "back oils" as a present for Tara. Suggests some nice imagery for moi ....
    wolliw
     


    Thread Subject: Discussion S5E6 -- Family

    Postby Spring » Thu Nov 09, 2000 9:30 am

    posted 11-09-2000 11:30 EST (US)
    I thought it was 'bath oils' you naughty freudian be-slipped vixen!
    Spring
     


    Thread Subject: Discussion S5E6 -- Family

    Postby april » Thu Nov 09, 2000 9:31 am

    posted 11-09-2000 11:31 EST (US)
    actually, i think he said "bath oils", but the image is still a nice one...

    i have so much i want to say about "family", but no time to type it! i depart on a 4-day trip to atlanta in an hour...

    april
     


    Thread Subject: Discussion S5E6 -- Family

    Postby wolliw » Thu Nov 09, 2000 9:41 am

    posted 11-09-2000 11:41 EST (US)
    Oops, thanks spring, April -- I stand bashfully corrected! (In my dialect of English, I pronounce 'bath' with the vowel like the one in 'father'.) I was wondering why no one seemed to have mentioned this; but "bath oils" is still nice, if for some reason less naughty-sounding ....
    wolliw
     


    Thread Subject: Discussion S5E6 -- Family

    Postby xita » Thu Nov 09, 2000 10:08 am

    posted 11-09-2000 12:08 EST (US)
    Adrienne, that's cause Willow's the butch

    I just wanted to say again, that Tara had better looks for willow during the dance. Willow's best looks were when Tara comes inside the covers, and she's looking up at her.. ahhh.. and when she says my dance. I also noticed Aly's voice was much softer than the more hysterical tone she sometimes gets when she's emotional. It was weird at first, but it's kind of cool.

    xita
     


    Thread Subject: Discussion S5E6 -- Family

    Postby april » Thu Nov 09, 2000 10:14 am

    posted 11-09-2000 12:14 EST (US)
    oh, i think baths can be pretty darn naughty, too...

    spring, once again we're on the same wavelength. found any good toys, er, "crystals", lately?

    those naughty wiccans...

    april
     


    Thread Subject: Discussion S5E6 -- Family

    Postby heathergalaxy » Thu Nov 09, 2000 10:22 am

    posted 11-09-2000 12:22 EST (US)
    i'm soo sad! i didn't have enough time to write my critical analysis tonight... oh well...

    but i did want to mention a few things.

    i'm thinking the sally thing was a red herring. yknow, joss trying to slip us up and make us think that this had to do with doppelgangland... which we all totally fell for!

    i totally saw the footsie, the brush, and the hand... i also saw that look tara gave as buffy is looking for dawn. my interpretation was that tara was thinking 'good. buffy is taking care of dawn like she is supposed to.'

    did anyone else notice the clothing color scheme for family? very deliberate, imho...

    i'm just glad we solved the 'is that xander or xander's dummy?' issue!

    heathergalaxy
     


    Thread Subject: Discussion S5E6 -- Family

    Postby tyche » Thu Nov 09, 2000 10:26 am

    posted 11-09-2000 12:26 EST (US)
    My computer has been broken for the last few days (in fact, it broke on Sunday night so maybe the extreme joyfulness after reading the spoilers had something to do with it), but I just wanted to say that, from what I've seen & heard, it looks like an amazing ep. Amber looked totally gorgeous.. *sigh* And the cuteness factor! And W & T on a bed together! And the return of MKF! And I have to stop now or I am just going to gush for hours. But I am SO glad that W & T finally got to act like a couple in public. (Is it the first time this season that they've been able to do something traditionally 'coupley'? Not having seen S5 I am ignorant on this - it's only when you actually see an ep that things like this hit you..)
    Joss is a genius. Let us worship him.
    tyche
     


    Thread Subject: Discussion S5E6 -- Family

    Postby xita » Thu Nov 09, 2000 10:56 am

    posted 11-09-2000 12:56 EST (US)
    I don't think Tara looking at Buffy and Dawn is significant. I actually saw this as a walk in the shoes of Tara day. In that first scene, we something we had never seen. We see her react to the other people in the gang. We know she thinks xander is a sweetie. When riley and xander are wrestling, we see her reaction, she thinks they are funny. When she sees Buffy's caring for Dawn, she approves. When she throws in an awful joke, she is self depricating I loved this more a lot. Poor Tara, there's been so much going on that we haven't seen cause she's so good at putting up a good face.
    xita
     


    Thread Subject: Discussion S5E6 -- Family

    Postby Little Willow » Thu Nov 09, 2000 10:58 am

    posted 11-09-2000 12:58 EST (US)
    Welcome from lurkerdom, November!
    Little Willow
     


    Thread Subject: Discussion S5E6 -- Family

    Postby Little Willow » Thu Nov 09, 2000 10:59 am

    posted 11-09-2000 12:59 EST (US)
    For everyone wondering about Beth --

    Tara calls her "Cousin Beth" when they first arrive. You'll notice that the
    voiceover was looped; the close captioning initially reads simply, "Hey,
    Beth." I believe in postproduction they realized they had to make clear
    Beth wasn't a sister, or even mother, to those who weren't certain.

    If Beth hasn't hit 20 yet, that could be why she didn't know the truth and
    still believes in the "demon."

    If she has, it was theorized that she could be from a different side of the
    family that "doesn't" have the "demon" in them - could even be adopted, or a
    girlfriend / married into the family, otherwise not blood related, et al.

    If she has, she could also have just been told she looks like a demon, etc.
    Mental abuse can make you think things and see things that aren't there.
    Think of the Twilight Zone classic... It's all about the eye of the
    beholder.

    Speaking of Twilight Zone:

    Why oh why did, the very second Beth appeared, I instantly relate Twilight
    Zone to her? I think it was a combination of the ballerina from "Five
    Characters in Search of an Exit" and the blond woman in an episode I cannot
    recall the title of - Someone, anyone, have the title for this? - The
    episode that dealt with the folk legend of the two friends, the brunette
    ex-involved with a man and the blond about to marry him, when the brunette
    casts a spell (with the help of the local witch-type) to make the man turn
    to her instead.

    Does anyone else see this TZBeth issue or am I completely alone?

    Little Willow
    feeling old ::

    ----------------------
    "Magic." -- Willow http://www.amberbenson.net/ http://little__willow.tripod.com/wpwp.html http://www.gist.com/tvclubs/fanclub.jsp?fanclub=buffy

    Little Willow
     


    Thread Subject: Discussion S5E6 -- Family

    Postby Little Willow » Thu Nov 09, 2000 11:04 am

    posted 11-09-2000 13:04 EST (US)
    Scrolled around and one more topic to address for now: Dawn.

    Willow and Tara have both been very Dawn-supportive since REAL ME.

    Some quick examples. Including but not limited to.

    Willow has consisted let Buffy confide in her about Dawn's 'annoying' level, but she relates to Dawn due to 'spaz' and tries to get Buffy to go easy on her.

    NOTE when Willow calls the younger girl "Dawny" (Donny, much?) in RM.

    Tara had the thumb wrestling with Dawn, the discussion about Dawn with Willow, et al in Real Me. Then in Family we distinctly see various reactions shots (go Joss) of Tara regarding Dawn.

    As per Tara's "sense" of things (see Hush, TYG, Superstar, WtWTA and more) - I wouldn't be surprised if she beyond anyone else DID know more about Dawn, by either her studies, her knowledge, or simply her 'sense.'

    Little Willow


    --------
    "Magic." -- Willow
    http://www.amberbenson.net/
    http://little__willow.tripod.com/wpwp.html
    http://www.gist.com/tvclubs/fanclub.jsp?fanclub=buffy

    [This message has been edited by Little Willow (edited 11-09-2000).]

    Little Willow
     


    Thread Subject: Discussion S5E6 -- Family

    Postby spuckie » Thu Nov 09, 2000 11:07 am

    posted 11-09-2000 13:07 EST (US)
    Little Willow - if yer feeling old, i must be fossilizing as we "speak"...

    anyway, yeah, cousin beth's reaction to the non-demon truth was abit odd. Did she know all along it was a ploy to keep down the womenfolk? Does she still believe she and/or tara are demons?

    'nother question, DearOlDad said "the women in our family" are demons. Did he mean HIS family (passed down from the father) or tara's mum's family?

    spuckie
     


    Thread Subject: Discussion S5E6 -- Family

    Postby Spring » Thu Nov 09, 2000 11:16 am

    posted 11-09-2000 13:16 EST (US)
    Thanks for explaining that bit of clunky 'Cousin Beth' dialogue. I was watching with a friend and we both **groaned** when she said that. I guess it was Joss's call to explain Beth's presence, though I would've preferred that Beth's connection to Tara remain ambiguous- it would've been fun to wonder if she was a jealous ex-g/f or something. Not to say that hasn't been ruled out- looking at Tara's family, kinfolk-a-couplin' might not be a completely taboo concept.
    You know, it's people like me with our anti-redneck-backwoods stance and ready incest jokes that kept Tara in the closet about her ancestry. I'm ashamed of myself.....kinda. Willow is such a good girlfriend, and such a better person than me
    Spring
     


    Thread Subject: Discussion S5E6 -- Family

    Postby ghaliya » Thu Nov 09, 2000 12:18 pm

    posted 11-09-2000 14:18 EST (US)
    Interior Design comment.

    I *loved* that new poster in Tara's room. The one with the faces on it. It really adds mystery/complexity to her space. Does anyone recognize it - or know where I can buy one?

    ghaliya
     

    PreviousNext

    Return to Board index

    Return to Novogate Backup Kitten

    Who is online

    Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 8 guests


    Powered by phpBB The phpBB Group © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007
    Style based on a Cosa Nostra Design