xita wrote:
Willow/Tara fans certainly learned patience as we had to wait almost a year for a kiss and that was after they were officially a couple. I don't mind the waiting, but it doesn't quite make sense with any kind of story, unfortunately.
I feel the exact opposite. While I wasn't an active Kitten (or even a Buffy fan) during the airing of those pivotal W/T episodes (I remember becoming fanatic in the time period during the US airing of "Normal Again", so I had lots of "back history" episodes to hold me over so to speak, and, of course, at the same time having to deal with the whole Joss and ME falling out, those are still some scarily vivid memories btw... brrr), Otalia (canon) to me feels a bit more fleshed out classic storytelling-wise and
when you think about it old-school soap opera-wise it makes perfect sense to wait. Then again, I guess it's hard to compare two totally different genres (weekly fantasy show vs. daily soap opera), but IMO it's still very interesting to try . So I shall, since I'm a love-whipped geek.
It's a bit of a long ramble, beware! (Blame it on a serious lack of Otalia this week... a girl's gotta get her fix somehow!)
What makes Otalia special in my eyes is that you can begin canonizing the love story all the way back to when Olivia and Natalia were the two women battling it out over Gus' "heart" (and yes, I'm shamelessly using the expression ). IMO this rivalry should be included in their story because without it, you couldn't grasp the scope in how far they've come along in their relationship. So basically their story begins in January 2008. Olivia becomes ill and (because of Alan's badgering) starts interfering between Gus and Natalia. From that point on up until Olivia realizes she might be in love with Nat, we've got a year's worth of scenes building up to that conclusion (January '09 has the M2M presentation, which in my opinion really started to snowball it all). The build-up and investment, is what makes the falling in love so credible.
Now, let's compare that to W/T (with the emphasis on
canon; I still believe that's an important distinction to make, even after all these years). A whole different show, different format, different time perhaps? (in terms of a social mindset, "Girls kissing? Blasphemy!", but also in terms of technological advances, for instance, there was no youtube... woa, let that puppy sink in for a moment!), different writers with different senses of responsibilities (ya think?! ahem, sorry, sarcasm with a fringe of bitterness), different everything really, except for the fact that damn, do I love our witches too or what? Otalia to me, is like Willow and Tara 2.0, the Jossian "Lesbian Cliche" Hell Redeemed; Soulmates FTMFW!
Willow and Tara and other f/f couples in all those different fandoms have cleared the way for this story to emerge. I feel it, because of the make up I see in the fandom. I see fans of Xena, I see J/7, I see O/A, I see Buffy, I see Bad Girls, I see BAM, I even see SiP!, I see them all coming together in Otalia.
Note:
the following comparison could also be made with other non-daytime shows. Except, maybe, The L Word. That show stands alone all by itself . So, Tara first arrives on the scene in Hush. Totally romantic btw, all with the longing gazes, silent handholding and the flying sodamachine. Not much was said, not a lot of screen time, but back in those days (where there was no such thing as The L Word, it meant THE WORLD to most of us, I know it certainly did to me). There wasn't a whole lot of building up the love story, it couldn't have happened anyway, Buffy was a 40+ minute weekly show, so the W/T story line mostly got scuffled under the Initiative rug, draped in subtext and off-screen spec. It wasn't up until New Moon Rising did the "regular" Buffy viewer finally get an L shaped clue bonked on their head. Hush was episode no. 10 (Dec 14th '99), NMR episode 19 (May 2nd 2000). In a scope of 9 episodes (granted, spread over a time period of 5 months), Willow and Tara met, fell in love and started a relationship. How much of that did we actually see on screen? I went back and checked some of the running times of the clips (sigh... dems were some good times huh? ). It's not really accurate, but if we would go by 5 minutes of real W/T screen time an ep, times 8, that would make roughly a wopping 40 minutes of actual "falling in love" screen time that we as an audience got to see (I'm not gonna count NMR, because by that time, W/T already had their 'ship smoothly sailing in sunny waters... before a little Oz storm interrupted, luckily, they weathered it out ... Or am I fanwanking this too and was it just all up to interpretation and open for debate?! Stupid subtext and metaphorical magic sex! j/k, I still love it, don't worry). Other clues had to be filled in by the way of fanficcing it and/or character-studying our way through off-screen magic-induced subtext (again, sigh... those were the days, was it not?) And once New Moon Rising happened, it was stated as that. Willow and Tara. Couple. Done deal.
Now, I can't go figure things out in the way of calculating Otalia's screen time last year, but let's say that when I got hooked I had to free a whole weekend to catch it all up. Though I could give a rough estimate from what I've seen: if a s/l is on in a regular ep, chances are that it runs for approximately 8 minutes give or take. Say a s/l is on maybe twice a week, that gives us 16 minutes. Times that with 52 and that's a whole lotta screen time peeps!
(So, Willow and Tara; 40 minutes vs. Olivia and Natalia; 800 minutes. It's kind of stunning really, but not much surprising. It's soap after all. Still, crazy that I hadn't thought of it before... when used for the forces of good, soap rules them all, when used for bad... yikes! But I digress...)
And according to what we've seen this week and last's, Otalia's STILL NOT OFFICIALLY in coupledom waters, even though they kinda already were and are and it is so totally obvious to us audiences and that's what makes it so deliciously frustrating and such great storytelling. We all get to SEE it. How ridiculous their protesting and wavering may be, we get to see aaaallll of it. And I'm placing a bet on it, that when they do get down with the dirty, we are gonna be privy in seeing that too.
Following along the same reasoning, the time between W/T's "outing" as a couple (that was NMR) and W/T first on-screen maintext kiss (9 months later in The Body), would go over really crooked when compared to Otalia (but this is future, hopefully very near future speculation on my part, since we haven't freaking seen it yet): I honestly believe that the minute those two decide, hey we're really REALLY a couple, that the kiss will soon follow, if not immediately, and even might go hand in hand (that is, realization = kiss, much in the same fashion as the "D'ya see? D'ya see now what they think?" kiss). Again, it's spec, so I'm probably wrong here.
Meh.
And maybe you could just all chalk this up to differences in taste and genre, but I still find this all very fascinating. Is patience a virtue? (never quite understood what that meant lmao). Maybe. I do know, that this patience will be rewarded (in terms of what it has taught me about story telling, it already has). Man and that makes me think of CBS again and how much they suck. Damn you CBS! Damn you!
Hee, I just thought of a great analogy. Pace-wise, Otalia's like EasierSaid's "Neverland" over at DCP! And we all know how much that story rawks!
Agnes Nixon knew her shit when she said: "Make them laugh, make them cry, make them wait." To me, Otalia is the true personification of that...
so...
have I fangirled enough for today?