I think there are lots of reasons why Tara is more of a "cult-y" figure than Willow... Hey, I could make a little list instead of studying Law. Anyone agree with me over these?
1. Amber Benson has never been in the credits (apart from *sniff * Seeing Red). So this made her more of an "underground" character, if you will... her name isn't on the back of the video boxes, etc, and when you watch an episode you are waiting for her name to come up as a guest star to know if she'll be on. Plus, a lot of time in magazine reviews or TV documentaries about "Buffy", she isn't interviewed.
2. Amber Benson is less of a mainstream actress than Alyson Hannigan - I think American Pie brought AH to non-Buffy audiences' attention (certainly in the UK, anyway) - but "Buffy" is very much AB's big TV break... if you are a fan of hers you really have to scout around for her other appearances, rather than checking out the local multiplex.
3. Tara is gay, and not gay in the sense Willow is, that is, after having a boyfriend etc. Of course sexuality is a very big spectrum but a lot of young gay people maybe don't know anyone else who hasn't really been all that interested in the opposite sex at all, and who have always been gay. It is unusual in female characters on TV, at least ones that stick around more than one episode after "turning" a straight girl!

If you are a young lesbian and everyone around you has boyfriends etc or has had them, and you can't relate to that... you can relate to Tara, who shows absolutely no interest in men sexually or romantically and who is secure in her sexuality and the fact she loves Willow.
4. Tara has been victimised but is a strong character at heart. Her mother is dead; her father and brother appear to emotionally and physically abuse her; she stammers, intially; she has to deal with her sexuality and the issues that brings; she's a witch... she's an outsider and a victim in a multitude of ways, but she's still a good person and over the course of the series grew in confidence. Look at her stand up to Anya in OAFA, the way she makes fun of Spike... you wouldn't have predicted that in Season 4! You really root for this girl.
5. Tara was made into more of a victim by the people who make "Buffy". She's always on the fringes of the Scooby Gang... she is brainsucked by Glory in "Tough Love" and now she is dead. This increases her cult status... being an outsider, being attacked, and sadly, being killed off. Have you seen how many Tara websites they are, how many people want her back?
6. Amber Benson's performance is pretty different to everything out there, plus the actress herself (despite being basically thrown off the show) has made every effort to promote the series and get involved in off-screen stuff e.g. writing stories and comics, attending conventions. Everyone who has met her has said how great she is, I don't think anyone has a bad word to say about this girl! She seems to have a lot of time for people, and has accepted being written off "Buffy" with good grace.
Tara is for me pretty much the ultimate cult figure. I guess I better get started on that tribute website. Not that it'll do any good, but it might look nice. Sigh.
Edited because I can't spell...
Edited by: themagicpixie at: 9/24/02 3:24:16 am