Skip to content


Thread Subject: Discussion Thread 2 - S5E16: "The Body"

DO NOT POST - Backup in Progress

Thread Subject: Discussion Thread 2 - S5E16: "The Body"

Postby Beautiful Tara's Girl » Sat Mar 03, 2001 4:36 pm

posted 03-03-2001 18:36 EST (US)
Think Mrs. Whedon knows about it?
Beautiful Tara's Girl
 


Thread Subject: Discussion Thread 2 - S5E16: "The Body"

Postby Catwoman » Sat Mar 03, 2001 4:41 pm

posted 03-03-2001 18:41 EST (US)
She's probably the one who told him to keep them! haha. I mean, come on, it's the hot lesbian witches after all
Catwoman
 


Thread Subject: Discussion Thread 2 - S5E16: "The Body"

Postby Roxton » Sat Mar 03, 2001 5:16 pm

posted 03-03-2001 19:16 EST (US)
If she doesn't know then Joss had better tell her fast. She might get upset if she found out he was keeping the outtakes all to himself.

[This message has been edited by Roxton (edited March 03, 2001).]

Roxton
 


Thread Subject: Discussion Thread 2 - S5E16: "The Body"

Postby xita » Sat Mar 03, 2001 7:00 pm

posted 03-03-2001 21:00 EST (US)
Ok this is a reply to scifiacid on something from the other thread. Yes, in Family they do show a shot of Stevenson's Hall right before Mr. Maclay knocks on Tara's room. Implication being that she is there in that hall. We know Willow lived there last year. Do both live there now? And did Tara paint her new room? Well in "the body" they made it sound like Tara could just go down the hall to check and see if the blue top was there. I am thinking they may live in the same dorm.

When Xander blames the crappy wallmanship in Willow's room, Willow replies, "Yeah, you can hear everything next door." I am pervert because all I could think was, Willow must give this a lot of thought because of what Tara and her get up to in that room.

xita
 


Thread Subject: Discussion Thread 2 - S5E16: "The Body"

Postby april » Sat Mar 03, 2001 8:14 pm

posted 03-03-2001 22:14 EST (US)
man xita, the shared brain was certainly working when we heard that quote from willow, because i was thinking exactly the same thing...what with all those "spells" and things that willow and tara are up to, i'm sure the neighbors hear some *very* interesting things...

anyone up for moving next door to them with me, and bringing a tape recorder?

april
 


Thread Subject: Discussion Thread 2 - S5E16: "The Body"

Postby jellytot » Sat Mar 03, 2001 9:00 pm

posted 03-03-2001 23:00 EST (US)
...must be a shared kitten vibe, 'cause my dirty little mind went to the various loud "spells," tummy rubbing sessions and various monkey love and tender Sarah McLachlan moments that could be heard through that crappy wallmanship...

Man, could this show possible have anymore code words for "the sex"?

-- jellytot :0)

jellytot
 


Thread Subject: Discussion Thread 2 - S5E16: "The Body"

Postby Chance » Sat Mar 03, 2001 9:35 pm

posted 03-03-2001 23:35 EST (US)
Hey folks,
So I'm new here, I've been reading for the past couple of days, and you all seem like incredibly intelligent people... and devoted Buffy fans. Obviously I liked you all instantly. LOL.

Honestly, I just wanted to put in a few words about ER and BUFFY, and Willow and Tara. Alright, I occassionally watch ER. Every once in awhile I catch it, and try to make sense of it. On Thursday, I caught ER. At first, when it was over, I was a little shell shocked. But, when I sat down and thought about it, I wanted to congratulate the writers. For the first time in television history, there was a show that accurately portrayed the agony of being in the position that Kerri and her friend are in. I have much sympathy for both of them. But Kerri has a valid reason to be nervous -- it's hard to be gay, out, and successful in a "more professional" field today. Furthermore, whereas some of the fans of the show might be quite comfortable with their sexualities, bear in mind this is Kerri's first time. I would doubt she's even sure of her own feelings yet. That's pretty much all I wanted to add about ER.

On to Buffy... I have so much respect for Joss Whedon and his creation. I have been a fan since episode one, and I have never deviated. Willow and Tara is one of the most incredibly sweet romances on television -- whatever the sexuality. More importantly, they are real. The road to romance for them has been rocky, but worth the wait. I'm so glad I get the privilage of watching them every Wednesday on my television.

Well, that's it from me. Thanks, if you got all the way to here.

-Chance.

------------------
"Desperate for changing, starving for truth, I'm closer to where I started, I'm chasing after you."

Chance
 


Thread Subject: Discussion Thread 2 - S5E16: "The Body"

Postby msgreeneyes » Sun Mar 04, 2001 1:31 am

posted 03-04-2001 03:31 EST (US)
Hi Chance. I'm relatively new to the Kitten Board, too. Love ER (Kim and Kerry), love Willow and Tara and agree with everything you said. Just one question. Where is that quote from at the end of your post?
msgreeneyes
 


Thread Subject: Discussion Thread 2 - S5E16: "The Body"

Postby april » Sun Mar 04, 2001 8:42 am

posted 03-04-2001 10:42 EST (US)
hi chance! welcome to the kitty board! at times, i think we can be one of the smartest buffy-related boards around. at other times, well, we just babble. but it's all good.

if you have a minute, drop by the Introduction Thread where you can introduce yourself and learn more about us! there are some way cool kitties here, as well as some crazy stalkers and mean moderators. it's best to learn which is which.

oh and hey guys, our buddy sarah kuhn already has her review of "the body" up at scifi ign! we all know how much she adores willow/tara and amber (a bit *too* much, if you ask me), so click on the link to head over there and see what she has to say!

[This message has been edited by april (edited March 04, 2001).]

april
 


Thread Subject: Discussion Thread 2 - S5E16: "The Body"

Postby BlackLab » Sun Mar 04, 2001 8:57 am

posted 03-04-2001 10:57 EST (US)
After watching The Body several times, and hitting the rewind button dozens of times, I've been making myself look at different things on-screen instead of letting my eyes focus where they would naturally. Well, that was a convoluted sentence. What I mean is: instead of letting my eyes follow the usual (faces and such), I saw little things like Tara drumming her fingers against her side when the four of them are in Willow's room, not speaking. And were T/W/X wearing the same outfits at the morgue as they were when Joyce was being wheeled off for her operation in that previous episode? I'll need to check that out.

Another thing to focus on during repeat viewings is vocal tone. I've watched the kissing scene over and over just to hear Willow's "Tara" and Tara's "Shhh. Darling" (or: "Shhh, darling" - I won't quibble). And notice the tightness in Anya's voice when she says "understand" in "But I don't understand.", before going on about the stupidity of mortality. That's the moment when Willow sees that Anya's hurting, not being tactless.

To respond to an off-topic bit earlier: I didn't know that a gun-owning, vegetarian, smoking, lesbian MD was a stereotype! The things I learn here! Xita, you're missing some great stuff by not watching CSI. Jorja Fox - what a name - has been getting more screen time lately.

BlackLab
 


Thread Subject: Discussion Thread 2 - S5E16: "The Body"

Postby tommo » Sun Mar 04, 2001 9:02 am

posted 03-04-2001 11:02 EST (US)
I bet Joss has been filming '400 kisses' for longer than we suspect....

------------------
I just know she likes Willow, and she already has one of those.

tommo
 


Thread Subject: Discussion Thread 2 - S5E16: "The Body"

Postby Hugin » Sun Mar 04, 2001 9:03 am

posted 03-04-2001 11:03 EST (US)
msgreeneyes, I'm chiming in, because I don't knew when Chance might see your question to respond. I believe the sig is taken from the first line of a currently popular song by Lifehouse, called Hanging by a Moment.

-len

Hugin
 


Thread Subject: Discussion Thread 2 - S5E16: "The Body"

Postby Roxton » Sun Mar 04, 2001 9:12 am

posted 03-04-2001 11:12 EST (US)
If both Willow and Tara are now living in Stevenson's Hall, then they are one step closer to moving in together. With Joyce's death this could happen before the end of the year.
Roxton
 


Thread Subject: Discussion Thread 2 - S5E16: "The Body"

Postby xita » Sun Mar 04, 2001 9:47 am

posted 03-04-2001 11:47 EST (US)
Oh, blacklab I know what you mean. I am watching for more things now. I watched the beginning, the christmas scene. I noticed how when they hold hands, their thumbs rub against each other for a while after they first hold hands. It's so natural for them to do that while they talk. It' so loving of them. I am in love with Willow and Tara being in love. HELP!
xita
 


Thread Subject: Discussion Thread 2 - S5E16: "The Body"

Postby Roxton » Sun Mar 04, 2001 10:17 am

posted 03-04-2001 12:17 EST (US)
Xita there's no cure for being in love with Willow and Tara being in love. The only thing you can do is sit back and enjoy the feeling.
Roxton
 


Thread Subject: Discussion Thread 2 - S5E16: "The Body"

Postby xita » Sun Mar 04, 2001 10:33 am

posted 03-04-2001 12:33 EST (US)
Roxton, yo are right, there is no cure Thank god .


------------------
Tara: Shh.
Willow: Tara...
Tara: Shh. Darling...

[This message has been edited by xita (edited March 04, 2001).]

xita
 


Thread Subject: Discussion Thread 2 - S5E16: "The Body"

Postby eekiboo » Sun Mar 04, 2001 6:36 pm

posted 03-04-2001 20:36 EST (US)
i've just re-watched The Body for the nth time. so here's what i observed re: Tara's attire.

look at her blouse in the Christmas dinner scene. her top has a low-cut V-collar which you can somehow see the edge of her right breast! ok, if one can see that, does that mean she doesn't wear a bra? OMG, i'm thinkin' nekkid fan fic (which i began reading thanks to the mocha and xfiles stories...) which would probably be easier for a quickie with W, ya know w/o the hassle? heh.heh. coz i also noticed in IWMTLY, her blouse had the same V-collar neckline but it wasn't as low as this one's.
peace

eekiboo
 


Thread Subject: Discussion Thread 2 - S5E16: "The Body"

Postby wiccie » Sun Mar 04, 2001 8:26 pm

posted 03-04-2001 22:26 EST (US)
I think W/T have realised the fun and convienience of "going commando";~)
wiccie
 


Thread Subject: Discussion Thread 2 - S5E16: "The Body"

Postby tvsurfer » Mon Mar 05, 2001 11:33 am

posted 03-05-2001 13:33 EST (US)
cinescape has their review of The Body up
http://www.cinescape.com/


Buffy,
the Vampire Slayer
"The Body"
***SPOILER WARNING***
Reviewed by Christine I. Speakman
"Mom."
"Mom."
"mom."
"mommy."
Joyce Summers, Buffy's mom, is dead. Not death by Glory, nor by vampire, nor by any monster; just death by natural causes. An aneurysm in the brain.
"Buffy the Vampire Slayer" is a fictional television show about a young woman killing vampires and other monsters. Each week her and her friends, the Scooby Gang, get into trouble hunting down that week's evil; escapism at its best. Every so often we get terrific filming, wonderful acting, terrific writing, exciting fights, scenes that move you to any emotion you want to name. And every so often we get outright brilliant episodes, "Hush," comes to straight to my mind.
This week's episode, "The Body," was more.
The first thing I noticed was the silence. The scenes were too quiet, but not an absolute quiet. These scenes became startling real when normal sounds, the zipper closing the body bag, were heard. A rib cracking during CPR. The silent flat line of the EKG machine, just the line no sound. Joyce's clothes being cut from her dead body. Hearing only the snapping of the bloody surgical gloves being removed after the autopsy. Watching the sheet being placed over Joyce's face. Buffy and Dawn looking up from the floor at Joyce's now uncovered face. Haunting.
Pain was made tangible: Dawn's cries and collapse as Buffy breaks the news of their mother's death; Willow's need to keep changing, to find the top Joyce liked. Anya's verbal stumbles, not understanding what she's required to do, the whys of death, the hurt. Xander's need to blame something, fight something, do anything. Not cheap tear-jerking scenes but honest grief.
Sarah Michelle Gellar's Buffy was incredible. From last week's closing, and this week's opening scene of simply saying "mommy" to her sudden calmness to her shock of referring to her mom as "the body." Commanding simplicity.
I'm not familiar with the behind the scene terminology; however, I am well aware that without those talents and mastery, this wouldn't have been the episode it was. Together everyone working on "Buffy the Vampire Slayer" has raised the bar of excellence.
Just one more little thing, did anyone else noticed that we didn't actually see Dawn touch Joyce. Hmmmm

[This message has been edited by tvsurfer (edited March 05, 2001).]

tvsurfer
 


Thread Subject: Discussion Thread 2 - S5E16: "The Body"

Postby april » Tue Mar 06, 2001 8:01 pm

posted 03-06-2001 22:01 EST (US)
hey guys...

the mighty big tv review of "the body" is up. and they actually manage to say some funny things while recapping such a horribly sad episode. observe:

quote:
Willow mentions that they need to hit the road, and in the background Xander agrees while Willow, without fanfare, silently mouths "I love you" at Tara. And THANK GOD that they finally seem to be treating their relationship with the subtlety it deserves. With the way things have been going this season, I had worried that Willow would someday say to Tara, "You know, I love you [turning to the camera] because I am GAY! You heard me, world! I dive the muff. I'm GAY GAY GAY GAY GAY!"

hee! is it so wrong that i would actually sort of enjoy hearing her make a declaration like that? tongue-in-cheek, of course. or tongue in something, anyway. ahem.

enjoy the review!

[This message has been edited by april (edited March 06, 2001).]

april
 


Thread Subject: Discussion Thread 2 - S5E16: "The Body"

Postby judy » Tue Mar 06, 2001 8:17 pm

posted 03-06-2001 22:17 EST (US)
I showed "The Body" to my best friend last night (she was away and missed it -- she doesn't generally watch "Buffy" but makes a point when I tell her it's a Joss-ep). My friend is a visual artist and I loved watching it with her because of this; she kept commenting on the camera work with awe (asking me early on if Joss had directed this as well as written it because the camera work was so far and above anything on TV and on the series in general). In particular, she noted the beauty of the composition of the shots and how this contributed to the emotional resonance of a particular moment or scene. I am very much a verbally-oriented person. So up until last night I had only had a rather inchoate sense of why the visuals were so affecting. I'm glad I got to see the episode again through her eyes.

I also talked to a good friend of mine tonight who caught the episode last week. She was saying how much the kisses moved her because they spoke to the depth and intimacy of Willow and Tara's relationship.

I have cool friends.

judy
 


Thread Subject: Discussion Thread 2 - S5E16: "The Body"

Postby Dazey » Tue Mar 06, 2001 9:24 pm

posted 03-06-2001 23:24 EST (US)
Cinematographically (is that a word?) speaking, BtVS in general is a standout in the television world, and Joss-directed eps in particular are head and shoulders above anything else. I can't wait for him to make a feature. (Okay, I can wait till he's done with Buffy.) In "The Body" the camera was so important that it almost functioned as a character, kind of like a Greek chorus, commenting subtly yet potently on the drama. And rewatching "Family" tonight (is it weird that even though I tape every ep, I still watch the reruns on Tuesday?) after just having seen "The Body" last week, Joss's brilliance as a director was obvious. There's a noirish quality to "Family" that, I realize now, heightened the sense of dread I felt throughout most of the ep...which really sucked when I didn't know how it was going to turn out.

Joss: brilliant but mean.

------------------
"Sometimes I go online, but...everyone's spelling is really bad. It's depressing."

[This message has been edited by Dazey (edited March 06, 2001).]

Dazey
 


Thread Subject: Discussion Thread 2 - S5E16: "The Body"

Postby judy » Tue Mar 06, 2001 9:51 pm

posted 03-06-2001 23:51 EST (US)
Dazey, yes, my best friend kept saying, "Joss NEEDS to make a feature-length film." And, of course, I absolutely agree.
judy
 


Thread Subject: Discussion Thread 2 - S5E16: "The Body"

Postby Warduke » Wed Mar 07, 2001 5:07 am

posted 03-07-2001 07:07 EST (US)
april, I tried to post that part in chat last night but it was to long, so I thought I'd post it here today but you beat me to it I also thought it was funny as hell
Warduke
 


Thread Subject: Discussion Thread 2 - S5E16: "The Body"

Postby tommo » Wed Mar 07, 2001 7:10 am

posted 03-07-2001 09:10 EST (US)
OK. I've seen it.

I want the world to know I've seen it.

But most of all, I wanted my gf to know I'd seen it.

I was upset the most by Anya. Her voice cracking when she said 'understand' and then that huge speech she launched into as though it was the first time she'd ever seen death. The irony of her situation didn't escape me, but her innocence and raw emotion was what touched me.

I hate seeing Willow cry. I can only thank God that she's got Tara there to comfort her.

Sigh.....

------------------
I just know she likes Willow, and she already has one of those.

tommo
 


Thread Subject: Discussion Thread 2 - S5E16: "The Body"

Postby BBOvenGuy » Wed Mar 07, 2001 9:51 am

posted 03-07-2001 11:51 EST (US)
quote:
THANK GOD that they finally seem to be treating their relationship with the subtlety it deserves. With the way things have been going this season, I had worried that Willow would someday say to Tara, "You know, I love you (turning to the camera) because I am GAY! You heard me, world! I dive the muff. I'm GAY GAY GAY GAY GAY!"

Okay, yes this made me laugh, but it also made me shake my head and sigh. I think Joss deserves this year's "You just can't win" award. First people complain that Willow and Tara aren't highlighted enough, that their relationship isn't given the respect and exposure it's due, etc., and then when Joss finally starts having Willow be open about who she is he gets slammed for that, too.

Grrr... Have I mentioned how much critics bug me?

------------------
Come visit Now Leaving Sunnydale - A Showcase for Buffy Fans and their Non-Buffy creations

BBOvenGuy
 


Thread Subject: Discussion Thread 2 - S5E16: "The Body"

Postby Anyalvr » Wed Mar 07, 2001 1:18 pm

posted 03-07-2001 15:18 EST (US)
Well, no matter how many 'gay' references
Joss puts in there, people will still continue to deny. And deny. And deny. Sometimes the shippers are so vicious that they refuse to let it go.

The thing it seems that every other week
Joss is putting in some sort of reference
or another - 'preaching to the choir baby',
'gay, lesbian-type lovers' 'hello, gay now',
'sometimes it makes you feel like giving up on men altogether', 'I wish they'd show me the stuff they do together' --- did I get them all? While it's nice to see Willow affirm that she is gay and isn't ashamed of Tara (and vice versa), I believe it is getting a little repetitive. It seems more and more often that Willow and Tara's gayness is being affirmed rather than recognizing their relationship as just like any other.
I mean, the equivalent of it would be if Buffy had stood up every episode and declared
"Riley is my boyfriend and I love him!" Well, not quite. But you get what I mean. I'd rather have W/T stuff in an episode be a private conversation or a romantic moment or something of that sort rather than another WE ARE GAY! reference.

Of course there are several reasons for this.
It's partially a way to inject humor into the episode, partially because of the censors, but msot of all, I think it's Joss thumbing his nose at the shippers and other people in massive denial. The thing is, I really don't care for what the shippers think, and it's clear by now that to a lot of them there's nothing Joss can do to dissuade them.

Okay, so what is my point in all of this? I agree with the reviewer, basically! We know Tara and Willow are two women in a lesbian relationship and that they're not ashamed of that. I don't need to be told that over and over.

Okay, rant over. I mean, these little moments are nice but enough's enough already. JMO.

------------------
"I tried to be unlovable/why couldn't you do the same?"

-(jewel)

"Spank us 'til Tuesday! We promise to be bad if you do!"
-(drusilla, angel)

Anyalvr
 


Thread Subject: Discussion Thread 2 - S5E16: "The Body"

Postby BBOvenGuy » Wed Mar 07, 2001 1:45 pm

posted 03-07-2001 15:45 EST (US)
I'm not sure you could have scenes like the kiss without the "lesbian gay-type lovers" stuff before. Joss has been slowly priming the pump, reinforcing that Willow and Tara are together so that when the time for the actual couple-type stuff comes the audience will be ready for it.

I think the turning point may actually have been "I Was Made To Love You," because that was when we didn't get the obvious declarations and instead got things like "Honey, in case you didn't hear me the first six thousand times, no more teleportation spells!" and the business with Willow checking out a girl. Sure, they were blantant declarations done mostly for laughs, but they were of a sort that would have worked with a heterosexual couple, too (and in the case of Willow checking out April, has been done with heterosexual couples since the dawn of time).

I suspect that Joss has turned a corner with W/T now and what we'll see is more of what we've seen in the past two episodes. Things like "Hello, gay now!" were good and necessary at the point where the show and the characters were at the time, but I don't think Joss will go back to them now.

------------------
Come visit Now Leaving Sunnydale - A Showcase for Buffy Fans and their Non-Buffy creations

BBOvenGuy
 


Thread Subject: Discussion Thread 2 - S5E16: "The Body"

Postby xita » Wed Mar 07, 2001 5:36 pm

posted 03-07-2001 19:36 EST (US)
I actually think that all the declarations had a reason. Gay now of course was necessary but so was the we are lovers in a gay sense... People were still in denial about what exactly Willow and Tara did together. In addition the honey one is amazing sigh. Just perfect. Willow checking out a girl, also necessary as a lot of people wanted to think that Willow would only be gay for Tara. Not the case. Ok, I hope that made some sense. I am tired
xita
 


Thread Subject: Discussion Thread 2 - S5E16: "The Body"

Postby Dazey » Wed Mar 07, 2001 7:58 pm

posted 03-07-2001 21:58 EST (US)
I was wondering too what was up with all of the pointed gay references...in my paranoid mind I was actually starting to worry that it might mean something bad--what, I don't know. But now that we've had The Kiss, I do think it may have been the writers "priming the pump," and I am the only one who thinks that sounds dirty? But also, Buffy and Xander don't need to stand up and shout, "Hey, we're heterosexual!" because they get to show it whenever and wherever they want to. I'm not even going to consider researching it, but was there ever a B/R couply ep where they didn't kiss or grope or boff each other's brains out? We get a lot of pointed demonstrations of heterosexuality, even graphic depictions of intercourse (which, I'm no prude, but ew)--obviously, we will never get anything even approaching this with W/T. I don't hear the critics complaining about that.

I think Willow's in-your-face gayness is a response to this, and I like it. I like that Willow is out and proud. OTOH, I don't want Willow or Tara to become defined by their sexuality, and it irks me a bit when I see them referred to as "Buffy's lesbian friends." Nobody's calling Xander and Anya "Buffy's straight friends." Subtlety is a virtue...but I really don't think that even one gay reference per ep is necessarily being unsubtle. Not as long as het lovin' continues to play such a major role in the show.

------------------
"Sometimes I go online, but...everyone's spelling is really bad. It's depressing."

Dazey
 

PreviousNext

Return to Board index

Return to Novogate Backup Kitten

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest


Powered by phpBB The phpBB Group © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007
Style based on a Cosa Nostra Design