Feedback, continued.
Cam
What a treat! Excellent misdirection my friend, you truly had me believing that Willow was Red (or the daughter of Red or something like that) and was about to be propositioned by a scaldingly hot Tara. Should have picked up (no pun intended) on:
Quote:
Tara let her hand graze lazily over the right front fender, the smooth metal hot under her fingertips
and
Quote:
Willow’s fingers paused over the keyboard as the blonde came into view. Expecting her to approach the office, Willow frowned slightly when the woman instead walked over to the pickup parked out front, sat down, and closed her eyes.
The “Red” who runs this type of service station wouldn’t be tapping on a keyboard in the office. But I soon got so engrossed at their mutual watching / drooling / baiting that I forgot these logical clues that you planted for us. Good job, cos who wants to be logical when the air was so full of heavy sexual innuendos? That entire exchange about the stuttering engine needing to be fixed was so darned hot! I mean, who hasn’t had a fantasy of a sweaty, tank-top clad Tara saying to them:
Quote:
“Maybe I just need to be jumped.”
The moment when Willow dismisses decimal points and numbers is a sure sign that her mind has gone completely elsewhere (you know, like Tara’s breasts?
).
I’m wondering how the real Red appeared to be so oblivious to the obvious hot lesbian loving going on. I mean they must have been flushed and panting with the … (*stopping before my imagination gets derailed*). Then again, Mr Morris seems to be a kindly elder gentleman and he’s probably too polite to say anything, or he lets on less than he knows. Now, if it’d been Anya …
Talking of evilness, so sweet of Willow to buy the truck for Tara. That was priceless, and I can just imagine how Tara would thank Willow, once they get back home. Oh wow, what about thanking Willow in the newly acquired red pickup? I’m drooling again …
Great stuff, oh Mistress of uber funnies!
*****
EmmyLast thing I want to do is to start comparing the 12 stories and saying which one is the “funniest”, “sweetest”, “most epic” etc etc. But I will, just this once, because I feel that
Winter Harvest is the most powerful of the stories. I think the others in the group won’t mind me saying that. You continued with the themes you painted in Sunflowers so well. Detailed and realistic descriptions are what we expect from you and you certainly didn’t disappoint. I have come to the conclusion that it’s your artist’s eye that makes your writing so pleasurable to read. It
is almost like looking at a painting.
Nice to see that even though they’ve been together that number of years, they still can’t stand prolonged separation. Sometimes a relationship fades when you spend too much time apart; or you develop habits that are not couple-y; or you get out of sync. Sigh, I’ll stop projecting now.
This Sunflowerverse Tara is one who, as she admits to herself, can be clingy. She seems to need the reassurance of her family. Perhaps it’s her history with her father, her brother running away, but it also manifests in her need to gain Sheila’s approval. But I like seeing these insecurities evaporate when she thought of Willow and Willow wearing a cardigan that held meaning for them.
Quote:
It was at that moment that Tara's heart began to swell with so much love for Willow that she was afraid it would burst under all the pressure. And at the same time she let all her fears about her father, brother and mother-in-law evaporate inside the cleansing power of her love for Willow.
I said in fb for Sally that I don’t believe that love alone conquers all. What you have shown us, is love and communication and working on the relationship – those combine to make the relationship work.
I’m not the most emotional person when it comes to reading fanfic (only a tiny handful of fics have ever made me cry) but when it became clear that it was Tara’s dad haunting her, a very noticeable tingle crept up my spine. If I were Tara, being alone in the farm, with a
Quote:
strange sense of not being alone that permeated every waking moment
I’d freak out. And the way you used smell, as opposed to sound or sighting, to suggest an otherworldly presence, that was so inspired. Smell is more subjective, but it’s also something we cannot avoid. We can close our eyes, use earplugs but smell is beyond our control. I am very happy that Tara’s dad made the redemption effort even in death.
Quote:
Tara vaguely wondered if the six live geese in her barn had been some kind of sign from her father
It’s too much of a co-incidence for it not to be.
Oh, Shylee. Love how you smoothly added her in. No need to introduce her, she is such a part of their lives that it’s natural for her to be included. No backstory, but we don’t need it, not at this point. In a way, I’m not surprised she can see her grandpa and Santa, children are more sensitive than us after all.
I’m not going to say anything about Sheila. That presumptuous, thoughtless [*insert description that combines bitch, poophead, unwelcome stupid person*] …. PINHEAD.
*****
ChrisRight off the bat, I lurved it.
Quote:
Summary: "Captain's Log, Stardate 53988.1: We're being pestered by Ferengi, and I'm in love with Tara."
How super, Super,
SUPER sweet!!! Readers of this story will be either Trekkers or non-Trekkers (duh, watty). But I finished it and my overwhelming reaction was … it didn’t matter. The background elements were there – the Palomino, the verse, the required elements – but ultimately, it
was about the crew being pestered by unwelcome visitors, and Willow being in love with Tara.
Given how you described it as a last minute effort, it didn’t feel like it one iota. The entire story flowed seamlessly from scene to scene; and from character to character. It didn’t take me long to be able to differentiate between the different personalities of the crew. Nite, Jem, Jack, Nurse … these names roll off my tongue (well okay, my keyboard) easily now.
I’m glad both W and T have close confidantes.
Quote:
"Evidently you haven't been doing so up until now. I'd stake a bar of gold-pressed latinum that the Captain is very interested in you."
Jack, aside from a figure to drool over, is a lot like Faith. Direct, no nonsense, a good foil for Tara.
Quote:
"There's a reason relationships between a captain and a crew member are discouraged," Willow countered wearily.
"Have you considered there's also a reason why they're not forbidden?" Nurse asked.
Oh how I love Nurse. I see her as the Fairy Godmother; her banter with Willow suggests that they really have built up a rapport, amazing considering she’s a hologram. And of course her “spell” with the mistletoe. Speaking of which
Quote:
"Positioning oneself beneath the herb indicates sexual consent?"
:lmao
And so to the gifts. Handcooked Christmas pud and ice cream, yums. Personal journal, very meaningful. Kissing under the mistletoe, so romantic. But my question is will Willow’s next gift to Tara be:
Quote:
"Myself, with a big bow wrapped around me,"
and will we get to read about it?
Great stuff. Including those Calandian carnivore bats and isodynamic field capacitors. 1 Adjective + 2 nouns works every time.
*****
CarBefore I get to Day 8, just want to thank you for doing this with me. We never thought it’d grow to something so awesome when we started the whole “lets ask a bunch of writers if they want to do a collaboration” project. It’s been a hell of an adventure!
Anyway, I’m glad that you took the plunge and joined the writing ranks this time, even though you were nervous about it. Rest assured,
AYCE is a smashingly wonderful story! You get the, what did I say, Awards for
Most Detailed and Carefully Written and
Most Shout-outs. So sorry I missed the second half of the creative process; HoMary – my sincerest thanks for stepping in, and at the last moment too.
Now then, feedback. And where shall I start? There’s so much of it!!!! I have to organize into different sub-headings. *deep breaths* here goes.
The LovebirdsI’m with HoMary on this. Sweatpants, grungy sweater, disheveled hair. And Tara
still gets turned on by her Willow. Wowza. Yes, they are
Quote:
Blissfully, deliriously hopelessly
in love. So great to see that even after 6 years the spark is still there. Perhaps slightly unrealistically, cos honestly, how many relationships can still keep up with the honeymoon / constant hunger / blind lust stage after 6 years? But like you will say to me, this is supposed to be a happy, fluffy, angst-free story. (btw, when are you gonna try your hand at angst?
) I’m referencing
Candle a lot, but here is obviously a Willow and a Tara who have worked to maintain their relationship and not let it slide. Willow is happy about Tara volunteering at the youth center despite her protestations about Tara staying home so they can have sex; and Tara knows Willow well enough to know that even with the prospect of an all-nighter AYCE Tara-buffet, Willow will want to finish debugging her program first. It’s not about compromise; it’s about deep understanding.
There are so many moments that exemplify their love, and I especially adore the constant teasing, innuendos and double entendres that dot their conversations during the day.
Quote:
“You don’t…have…to be…alone,” Tara hummed between kisses on any piece of exposed skin within her reach. Finishing – for the moment – with a quick bite on an accessible nipple, she looked at her flustered girlfriend and continued. “Come with me.”
Heehee. Snerk.
Plus the entire exchange, to create this amount of desire in the middle of a dozen screaming kids,
Quote:
“Kids are here.”
“I know.”
“I want you.”
“I want you too.”
“Not here.”
“I know.”
“Later.”
“Definitely.”
“I love you.”
“I love you too.”
So cleverly done. And yes, you’re soooo right (as usual), it doesn’t matter who says which line. I bet every reader
hears a different version. And that is why it is one of the standout passages for me.
I also love the similar thoughts as they see each other with the kids. I want my relationship to be just like them, you’ve crafted two people so obviously in love, and with a positive future to look forward to. Brilliantly done.
The kidsQuote:
“Remember, Sweetie, you don’t have to play with the kids. You’re here for me, not for them.” Tara smiled at her girlfriend and gave her a quick wink. “Ready?”
Willow nodded and squeezed Tara’s hand. “Yep, I’m ready. They’re just kids. How bad can it be?”
There is such a “famous last words” quality about this. It didn’t prepare Willow for the Kiddie Stampede, or us either.
When I was in college, I volunteered at a youth centre every Saturday morning. I taught the same class of kids over a 5 year period. We were supposed to teach different classes, but somehow I managed to get myself “assigned” to the same group of kids every year. I watched them grow up. They are accountants and computer programmers now, but I still remember them when they were young. My point? To quote Willow,
Quote:
These kids are a riot.
And do I sense a theme? Let’s see:
Cam with a
big crush on Miss Willow. And who gets the most lines! I especially got a bellyful of laughs out of
Quote:
“Are you gonna kiss?!”
and
Quote:
“I think you’re pretty. So, I wanted to put you on my cow.”
such a great pick up line.
Sally, also with a crush on Miss Willow, who rescues Gabrielle and makes toast of all sorts of baddies. So full of energy, that one.
Emmy’s nurturing tendencies and whose art tells stories of two girls who are best friends and are always seen hand in hand.
‘Take no nonsense’ Debra who has a bestest friend Rachel and who is unfazed at the sight of scantily-clad women dancing and who in fact is the creative director / choreographer for their efforts.
Mammary mania Terra, who utters the immortal line:
Quote:
“Boobiesboobiesboobiesboobiesboobies.”
and who is going to marry Miss Tara one day.
Budding psycho-ologist Mary, whose crush is on Miss Faith and who almost pleads:
Quote:
“Oh yes! You can keep me, Miss Faith!”
Cyd, who is not only good with wood and Wonder Woman action figures but
Quote:
picked up the Giganta doll and unceremoniously tossed her aside, out of sight.
ooooh butch tendencies from Cyd-let! And I was under the impression that she’s mellow.
Am I right in saying this is a very, um,
gay group of children? *squeals in delight* How awesome!
Not so sure of the preferences of VP of Networking “Yes. I borrowed my sister’s Barrel of Monkeys, but they don’t work.” Justin; or music expert Maru (btw, love her beta-ing of Terra’s cow); or Janna the botanical expert. Chris might seem the odd one out, with his action figures and crush on Miss Tara. But he redeems himself with his artwork and inspired usage of Lara Croft and Supergirl.
And finally we come to Watty the
outstanding kid in the whole bunch.
Quote:
“Oh, what did I do now?” Harley mumbled under her breath.
Heehee, even Miss Harley trembles at the sight of those two frolicking duckies on her little cardigan.
Quote:
“Oh, it’s not my real name. I don’t like my real name. I do think it’s quite silly.”
Oh my god. Dude.
Excellent. Excellent. You made the kids virtually central characters in this story and they are a pleasure to read. I will be the first in line to read any further adventures involving Pirate Cam, Amazon Sally and all the other kids. Wonderful.
The other adultsYou really did a good job in a) mix’n’matching the other adults and b) capturing their voices. From the
Quote:
“Quirk? Quirk! Huh! Just because someone wants a little of her own personal space, she suddenly has a ‘quirk’. Well, that’s just peachy!”
screech of ‘Own OCD Category’ Kathy (btw
Just Peachy is Miss Alli’s nickname for Jeff Probst, the host for Survivor, and here endeth the trivia lesson for today) to Glory’s
Quote:
she’s sassy
they give an extra dimension to the story but without taking the limelight away from the lovebirds or the kids.
Especially love Faith
Quote:
”I especially like that Mary kid. Gotta appreciate anyone who thinks I have a great rack.”
The image of 12 kids dog piled on her will stay with me for a while.
And Oh.My.God. Xander and
Dru?? Buffy and
Parker?? *snickers*
Very provocative and evocative number the 8 maids-a-milking put on. Love the description of the costumes, I could picture them very clearly. Well, it helps that I’ve seen a rough sketch, but even without that drawing, you made the whole sequence come to life.
And not forgetting how well you wrote yourself. It’s not easy to do, write a larger than life version of yourself and not end up sounding contrite or silly. My favorite Harleyism:
Quote:
Suddenly – and with very little grace – a body that decidedly did not belong to a child flopped onto the floor beside Tara. “I want my mommy.”
This is a beautiful, funny, loving, sweet and 100% angst-free story. Perfect candy for the season. Thanks for taking up the challenge, you delivered 3000%!
[br]