Author: Alcy
Rating: PG-13 all the way, I'll warn ahead if it changes.
Disclaimer: The characters of Willow, Tara, Buffy, Xander, Dawn, Anya and Spike etc aren’t mine, they belong to TPTB, I’m just playing with them for a bit. Also a warning: Angst level is going to get quite high.
Summary: This fic begins directly after Season Six Episode ‘Tabula Rasa’ and explores my view on what would happen if Tara didn’t leave Willow at this point. Deals with how the magic addiction as seen in ‘Smashed and ‘Wrecked’ would play out if Tara was there along. Be ready for much angst people! However, not only do we have to deal with Willow's addiction but also the Scoobies latest Sunnydale menace! Get ready for pancakes, warlocks, omnipotent vampires, general hell on earth, Buffy, Spike - all your favourite main characters from season six and of course much W/T schmoochies...much fun, I guarantee it
Feedback: Most welcome
Worst Nightmare
Chapter One
Willow drew her knees closer to her chest, hugging them with her arms as though that would put an end to the sobs shaking her body. The walls of the bathroom seemed to be closing in on her, suffocating and she willed that they would fall and crush her.
“God what is wrong with you?” Willow flinched even now when she remembered Tara’s harsh words the previous evening.
Tara thought that she was wrong…her Tara, her everything thought she was wrong. In just one sentence Tara had managed to tear a great gaping hole in her heart that refused to close. Willow had never understood why Tara was always on her back about the amount of magick she was using, always nagging, trying to curb what came so naturally to Willow. Why would you even want to curb something that could be used to help so many people? All she wanted to do was help, save as many people as she could from hurt and suffering. Buffy…Tara…all her friends. Willow knew she had the power to do it. Before she had discovered the magicks, she was just plain old Willow. Back then her helpfulness had been limited to whatever she could do on her computer or as ‘old reliable’ taping Biography every Friday. Now she had power…and wasn’t it a good thing? However, if it was a good thing then why did everything turn out so radically different from what she had intended? Why was Tara leaving her when it was magic that had brought them together in the first place? The only answer that kept repeating over and over in her head was that Tara would never be able to understand how it felt to have the power to really do something about people’s problems and how very necessary it was to possess that power. However, for all her reasoning, it was an answer Willow drew absolutely no comfort from.
*****
Tara clumsily folded the shirt in her trembling hands into something that resembled a scrunched up shirt and placed it in the box on the bed. She started to move to the chest of drawers when a feeling of finality hit her like a brick. ‘Leaving’…all of a sudden Tara hated the word with a passion and what it meant for her relationship with Willow. Was it over…like totally, irreconcilably over? Her legs suddenly turned to custard and gave out on her completely as she flopped onto the edge of the bed. She put her elbows on her knees, resting her head in her heads. Wearily Tara rubbed her temples as if the act of rubbing would make everything go away and they would forget this. She stifled a rueful smile…Willow had already done that to her once.
“I don’t need magic, I don’t, let me prove it to you okay, I will go a month without doing any magic. I wont do a single spell I swear…” and she had said it would be so easy to stop, like she was giving up something trivial and not nearly so addictive as her magicks.
All Willow had proved to Tara was her capacity to hurt her lover even further, to lie, to betray. The path to self-destruction all too clearly paved. However, even with the score mounting up against Willow, Tara knew that if she walked out she would be removing the one thing that stood between Willow and an incredibly dark place. A dark place that someone with a soul as inherently good as Willow’s did not belong no matter what they had done. She was gripped by awful images of Willow suffering and in pain. Just the mere thought of it caused her to choke back a sob. At that instant Tara knew she would die before she let Willow go anywhere near that place.
*****
Willow finally managed to drag herself up from the floor. She walked to the basin and bent down and splashed her face liberally under the faucet, shivering slightly as the cool water hit her flushed skin. It rinsed away the tears that had streaked her face but not the rank feeling that encased her heart. Like a zombie she stumbled back into the room she had shared with her lover, her life. More than anything, she dreaded the gut wrenching feeling she knew would come with Tara’s absence. However, knowing she deserved every rotten feeling of guilt and betrayal that came her way meant that she needed to face it.
Despite all her resolve, Willow was still unprepared for the sight that greeted her when finally returned to the bedroom. She stopped in the doorway and had to grip the doorframe with both hands to stop herself from keeling over as the blood rushed to her head. Tara was still there…
She was sitting on the edge of the bed, staring blankly at a box full of awkwardly piled clothes that lay at her feet. She looked up slowly when she noticed Willow in the doorway and her features hardened into a mask, not of revulsion as Willow might have expected, but resolve. It tool a few moments for Willow to remember how to talk and even then, it wasn’t very coherent…even for Willow.
“You packed…there’s a box…which means you’re leaving, aren’t you leaving? A box usually means leaving.”
All Willow could think about was Tara leaving, instead of rejoicing in the fact that she was still here. She knew full well that it was because Tara had no reason to stay after what she had done to her. Any thoughts of Tara staying wouldn’t register in her coherent thoughts. Yet another part of her mind was screaming at her to rush over and throw herself at Tara’s feet as she desperately begged her forgiveness. Willow wanted to assure Tara that she would never ever use magic again, or hurt her in such a way. Even in her present state, Willow still knew that all the sincerity she possessed wasn’t enough to convince Tara of such promises, no matter how heartfelt they were.
Tara didn’t reply to her question immediately, probably because she knew that whatever words tumbled out of Willow’s mouth first were bound to make very little sense. She didn’t realise how hard it would be to look at Willow after what she had done. Usually it was so easy, Tara never needed an excuse to gaze at her love unashamedly. Whether it was while she was slightly flushed as she was late and scurrying to get ready for a class, serenely asleep in the moonlight or bathed in a coat of sweat while Tara was making love to her...she was always beautiful and complete. Now the images came scattered, fragmented, a delicate face framed by red hair which still clung damply in places from where she had splashed her face with water, teary green eyes staring from amongst a scattering of freckles and her lips…lips. Tara tore her gaze away when unbidden thoughts of sweeping Willow into her arms and claiming those lips fiercely crept over her.
Wrenching her legs out of their frozen state, Willow crossed to the bed and sat beside Tara. Not too close as though to invade her space, but not too far as though to deny the hope she dared to feel. Minutes passed, Willow and Tara barely moved a muscle save to brush an errant strand of hair, or smooth a non-existent clothing wrinkle. It was not an uncomfortable silence, but nor was it the loving silence they previously enjoyed sharing.
Tara just wanted to curl up and go to sleep with Willow in her arms; surely they could talk about this tomorrow?
Willow just wanted to apologise…she had to have Tara’s forgiveness in order to feel whole again.
“Willow,” Tara finally spoke up at the precise moment that Willow whispered, “Tara.”
“You first,” they both said in unison, followed by matching awkward smiles.
Seeing that they were having no luck with words, Tara reached out and cupped Willow’s cheek, rubbing the soft skin gently with her thumb. Willow reached up and placed her hand over Tara’s as she felt tears burning her eyes again. They looked up and into each other’s eyes; it was as thought they were looking into a mirror when they found an expression of pain in the other’s eyes to match what they were feeling inside. Pain that would not be fixed by any infinite number of words. A pain that would either be healed by the passage of time or intensified by it. For the moment they could only deal with their immediate concerns.
“You’re not leaving?” Willow asked softly, impassively.
“I’m not leaving,” Tara replied.
“W-why?” Willow choked the word out, trying to restrain any remotely joyous feelings.
Willow watched as Tara’s soulful sapphire eyes filled with tears before the blonde withdrew her hand and ducked her head as she bit her lip to keep from sobbing aloud. Tara composed herself, drawing in a deep breath before meeting Willow’s eyes once more.
“Because Willow, you complete me,” Tara spoke evenly, “I just know if I walk out that door I’ll be leaving a part of me behind…and it’s the part I want to hold on to more than anything.”
“But what about the magicks?” Willow had to ask it even though she knew it could ruin everything.
Tara sighed, “I won’t let that tear us apart, I love you and will do whatever it takes to help you. Right now…that means staying with you…even though…”
“Even though I betrayed your trust…violated you twice…” Willow whispered, her voice tinged with shame.
“Will, I love you alright, now stop it with the self-loathing already. What’s done is done and however wrong it was, I don’t want you to spend the rest of your life hating yourself for it…or trying to make it up to me. We need to step back from where we were in our relationship, start afresh. Not quite clean slate beginning, but a beginning nevertheless.”
Willow managed the tiniest of genuine smiles resulting purely from her love for this woman sitting on the bed beside her who was beautiful in every way possible. She knew with a stab of guilt that it would be a long time before the self-hatred ran its course. It was difficult not to hate herself when she knew that she, Willow, was the one aspect that sullied Tara’s otherwise pure existence. She was the nightmare intruding on what was a very pleasant dream. She felt guilty for just being with Tara…yet Tara loved her. Willow made a tentative move to embrace her lover but Tara quickly held up her hands, stopping her in her tracks. Willow was momentarily hurt but it didn’t take her long to understand where Tara was coming from. These things took time and patience. No matter how much they both wanted a quick resolution to their pain, mostly in the form of steamy and drawn out make-up sex, it wasn’t going to happen.
Tara had always been the stronger of the two when it came to having a clear head and yet she had to fight back the urge to seek out every inch of Willow’s skin with her mouth.
“A beginning Will,” she wiped her sweaty palms on her thighs, “It’s just a beginning."
Chapter Two
“That is one ugly looking oogly-boogly,” Dawn said enthusiastically as she leaned on Xander’s shoulder and pointed to a picture of a particularly wart-encrusted demon, “Whatcha looking at him for, he next on our list of baddies to tackle?”
“Err, no,” Xander replied closing the book and setting it aside, “I was just looking through Anya’s family album.”
Dawn bit her lip and looked anxiously to the counter, hoping the blonde-haired ex-demon hadn’t heard her dig at her uncle or cousin…pet…whatever it was. Luckily Anya was far too engrossed in explaining to Tara the magical properties and potential of the latest shipment of some sort of pickled larvae from Australia. Xander and Dawn watched as Anya babbled about the profit margins while Tara eyed the putrid little lumps of maggot-like flesh with something between revulsion and fascination.
Dawn swallowed quickly and eyed the feather duster lying on a nearby shelf that she had been trying to lose all afternoon. Another few words to the tune of ‘ingesting a teaspoonful every day does wonders for bladder irritations’ from Anya and she seized the duster and marched to the front of the store to give the displays a thorough cleaning. Xander smiled, all the talk of larvae didn’t bother him after all the sights he’d seen in his days as a member of the Scooby gang…too much anyway. He looked across the table to where Willow was tapping away on her laptop. She glanced up at Xander with a quizzical expression.
“I’m not so sure Buffy heard the demon correctly when she said he was going out about the ‘Dawn of Uranus.’ I can’t find any reference to it at all on the net besides very naughty stories that I don’t want to come across again!” Willow announced resolutely and snapped her laptop shut.
“Well, she did have it in a headlock at the time…and his accent was pretty bad…it might be something else…maybe you should ask Buffy again,” Xander looked around the shop, “Speaking of the Buffster, where is she?”
“Oh, she’s out the back giving the punching bag the pummelling it deserves,” Willow waved her hand in the general direction of the training room as she busied herself staring at Tara out the corner of her eye.
“She’s been training a lot lately…like Olympic games standard training, ever since…since Giles went back to London.”
As Xander talked, Willow watched Tara contentedly. It amazed Willow that no matter what Tara was doing, she looked absolutely ravishing. Even as she was now, cautiously reaching into the jar of larvae to extract one with a large pair of tweezers. Willow watched her grimace when she punctured the skin of one, sending a spray of green slime around the sides of the jar.
“Hey, careful with the merchandise!” Anya scolded lightly.
Anya always had a soft spot for the blonde haired witch, Willow often thought she looked upon Tara as something of a pupil when it came to money matters…or maybe an experiment. Willow giggled when Tara pointed out a tiny dollop of slime on Anya’s cheek. Tara looked up and smiled at Willow before returning to her larvae extraction. The red head blushed for what must have been about the millionth time that day. She had blushed that morning when she had seen the curve of Tara’s breast as her robe slipped open after her shower, when their fingers had brushed during a class, when Tara’s breath fell lightly on her cheek as she leaned over Willow to look at the screen of her laptop. The last few days had been almost like falling in love all over again. Willow was so blissfully content in the knowledge that Tara loved her she hadn’t even thought about magic. Suddenly she was hit in the arm with a paper dart and looked up back to Xander with mock indignation on her face.
“Earth to Rosenburg, come in Rosenburg,” Xander made a beep-bop sound, trying to mimic a Star Trek-like communication sound, and then he did a high pitched girly voice, “Errr sorry Captain Kirk, I was just closely examining a Tara constellation.”
Willow looked apologetically at her childhood friend and picked up on his line of conversation, “Yeah, she hasn’t been around all that much lately…patrolling to the small hours of the morning. Whenever she is around she hasn’t said a lot. I mean, I can understand her being pissed at me because, hello, memory wiping and such but Dawnie notices it too. Yeah, worried.”
“What do you say we make a donut and coffee run. You look like you could do with some cool evening air and we all need a caffeine fix. Including our resident ‘insectologists’ over there.”
“Did you say something honey?” Anya asked not looking up from her inventory list where she was hastily scribbling money related notes.
“I’ll have a mocha and one of those donuts with the candy sprinkles,” Tara looked up from poking and prodding the bug.
Willow smiled warmly and stood up, stretching, “I’ll just pop out back and see if Buffy wants anything. She’s bound to want some sugary goodness.”
Willow wandered out back to the training room but before she had even walked through the door she had a suspicion that Buffy was no longer in there. She couldn’t hear any sounds of fists or feet striking the punching bag with Buffy-like intensity. Her eyes came to rest on an empty training room with no evidence that Buffy had even been there recently save for a scrunched up towel on the floor and a water bottle.
“No Buff?” Xander asked when she walked back into the store.
“Nope, must’ve gotten antsy and went patrolling.”
“Without telling us?” Dawn had moved back to the rear of the store when she heard her much absent older sister being mentioned by the gang, “She’s normally big with the telling…you know, so we know and stuff…in case she wants back up.”
“I’m sure she’s fine Dawnie,” Tara put aside her bug squeezing and crossed the floor to hug her surrogate little sister, “She’s just been needing a lot of space lately. C’mon, I show you what the larvae does when it comes into contact with water…it’s really cool.”
Dawn looked less than enthusiastic about the suggestion but allowed herself to be led over to the counter as Xander and Willow exchanged slightly nervous frowns. Willow sighed and picked up her jacket from where it was hanging on the back of her chair. Buffy was her best friend, they talked about anything. Yet ever since her resurrection, Buffy had distanced herself from Willow…unwilling to share her feelings despite Willow’s sympathetic ear. It seemed to Willow that between working things out with Tara and helping Buffy to adjust to being back that she had her work cut out for her. Willow wasn’t too daunted by either task, little moments with Tara made everything worthwhile, everything seemed so much easier and less frightening. They would help Buffy, that’s what the Scooby gang did.
*****
“You seemed a little tense after Buffy left this evening,” Tara was sitting on the bed brushing her hair as Willow tucked herself into bed much later that night.
Willow propped herself up on one elbow, “I’m just so worried about Buffy…I’m a little scared by the thought that she doesn’t want to be here…I mean…it hurts here.”
Tara nodded, “I feel the same way too…it does hurt and yet that’s why we’ve got each other…”
She paused for a few moments and the two witches shared a look they had become quite accustomed to sharing over the past few days. The look that said ‘I will always be there for you…no matter what.’
Tara continued, “…Xander, Anya, Dawnie, you…the Scoobies are family. Buffy knows we’re here for her.”
Willow nodded slightly and yet none the less resolutely. She would make sure that Buffy knew that…although not in the magic-fixes-everything kind of way she had become so used to resorting to. Right now though, it was her girlfriend that was foremost on her mind. She watched Tara finished brushing her hair, thinking how incredibly sexy she looked doing such a simple act. When Tara set down her brush on the bedside table and joined Willow under the covers, she looked across to see her girlfriend starting at her intently.
“What?” Tara asked softly.
“You’re awfully pretty,” Willow replied with a hint of flirtatiousness in her voice.
“Are you trying to sweet talk me Miss Rosenburg?”
“Nope,” Willow lied rather blatantly.
“C’mere you,” Tara extended an arm and Willow wasted no time in snuggling into Tara’s side.
Willow felt her tenseness melt away and her body relax as Tara enfolded her into her arms and ever so gently drew her backwards until they were both lying on the bed, warmth flowing between their bodies. Willow laid her head on Tara’s chest, listening to the steady thump-thump of her heartbeat and felt more relaxed than she had in a long time. There was a comfort in knowing that she was in a space where everything was perfect. There was so much love reflected in the simple act of lying next to her soul mate. A love that expressed itself just by the mere act of being.
“Tara?” Willow whispered as her head rose and fell slightly with Tara’s gentle breathing.
“Yeah Will?” came Tara’s sleepy response, punctuated by a small yawn and accompanied by her thumb lightly caressing Willow’s forearm.
“I need to ask you something really important…promise you won’t laugh at me?” Willow nuzzled against Tara’s chin.
“You know I’d never laugh at you…unless you deserved it of course,” Tara’s voice was tinged with a hint of the serious, despite being of a jovial tone overall.
“Can I have chocolate chip pancakes for breakfast tomorrow?” Willow asked in her most serious, big-favour-to-ask voice and added a loving hug to further help her cause.
“Go to sleep Will,” Tara grinned in the darkness and nestling her chin on Willow’s forehead.
Willow grumbled something inaudible but even Tara’s light chastening failed to put a damper on her snuggling efforts as she burrowed both furthered under the covers and even closer to her lover. Tara kissed the top of her head lightly and reached over to turn the bedside lamp off. For a few moments only the sounds of the two of them breathing were heard in the darkness.
“Does this mean I can have ‘em?” Willow piped up in an almost asleep whisper.
“It depends whether you shut up and let me go to sleep sweetie.”
“Kay, shutting up, quiet, asleep girl…” Willow whispered earnestly, “Shutting up, want…the chocolate chip…”
Willow’s breathing slowed as she fell asleep in mid sentence. Tara was left to continue lightly rubbing Willow’s arm, uttering a small prayer to keep her Willow’s sleep free of nightmares. Little did Tara know she desperately needed to say one for herself.
TBC
Edited by: KiwiAlcyone
Love sammi xx
What are we going to do with you?
But don't stop. It's sooooo good! I like! I'm liking that it's all complicated - Willow's conflict, the torment of needing Tara and needing the magicks at the same time, and Tara's trust/distrust of Willow.
..I can't wait for more..Love sammi xx
Love sammi xx
Willow upside the head! And I’m glad Buffy didn’t coddle her either, that’s the last thing she needs. Willow sounds so sure she’s through with the magicks, but I doubt it’s gonna be that easy!
And the whole, “Dawn of Uranus” had me